So you're telling me if you create a new folder on your desktop, that that folder and all its contents sync across all macOS and iOS devices? Are you sure? Everyone here seems to say just the files on the desktop not the folders on the desktop sync.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iCloud Drive - Desktop & Documents Folders
- Thread starter myname70
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
So you're telling me if you create a new folder on your desktop, that that folder and all its contents sync across all macOS and iOS devices? Are you sure? Everyone here seems to say just the files on the desktop not the folders on the desktop sync.
Experience – reading what was documented by Apple for Mac OS X 10.0, and so on.
I do not use iOS.
Folders that were present on my desktop from early pre-release builds of Mac OS X 10.12 appeared – and were populated – following a clean installation of a later pre-release of 10.12.
I performed a test with release build 16A323 of 10.12. The test appeared, and was populated, at https://www.icloud.com/#iclouddrive
I performed a test with pre-release build 16B2327e of 10.12.1. The test appeared, and is populated, at https://www.icloud.com/#iclouddrive
I can assure you that I can see ALL my desktop folders and the contents INSIDE them on my iPad, iPhone, MacBook Pro and iMac.
I want to know how to turn it off. The moment sierra installed, it had that 'optimize storage' option on. I turned it off and my documents folder was empty.
So I had to turn on the desktop and documents folder option (but kept that iCloud storage thing off). Eventually I want both off, but the entire setup is intensely confusing.
So I had to turn on the desktop and documents folder option (but kept that iCloud storage thing off). Eventually I want both off, but the entire setup is intensely confusing.
HERE is a helpful tip for everyone... if you have a FOLDER on your desktop named "Dropbox" change the name of it. I don't use dropbox, but I figured out my issue... since I named my folder DROPBOX Apple thinks it's ineligible for syncing, haha.
Nice glitch found (yeah it's a glitch!).... if I want to name a folder Dropbox, who is Apple to tell me I can't. Renamed it and it immediately sunk to iCloud.
Open the iCloud System Preferences window. Click on the question-mark button at lower left of window. That brings up relevant help.
I did not sign in when asked as part of the update process. All my documents, pix etc are still intact on my Mac.
Perhaps someday I'll turn on the cloud, but I don't like the idea of Apple pulling data off my Mac without giving me an option to say no first.
I didn't find that.
Optimisation was enabled only after I actively enabled iCloud Drive Desktop and Documents folders.
A cautionary tale about cloud syncing across multiple Macs: Maybe be careful with Sierra.
Files were lost.
Files were lost.
I wonder if the problem lies in the computer share name (no distinguishing difference if for example "Bill" owns three iMacs and all three have the same share name i.e., "Bill's iMac"?)
As I read the article, possibly not lost.
Also this statement was almost certainly wrong:
Still, it's a cautionary tale.
Agreed. See: http://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/09/24/marshall-desktop-documents (and the referenced arstechnica link).
A.
I have a feeling that they chose both places because that's where 99% or people store all their documents. And most those people don't pay attention on how they organize or set up backups etc...
I wonder if you can create a separate desktop that would really be a folder and use it that way?
If I have iCloud Drive for Desktop and Documents enabled and erase the computer (to sell), will the documents continue to be stored in iCloud? I'm wondering if when I setup my new computer the files will still be stored in iCloud or if they are removed when I erase the computer. With my photos stored in iCloud, and now my Documents folder, I would like to setup the computer as "new" and not from a time machine backup - pulling in documents and photos from iCloud. Thoughts? Thanks.
Yes, anything you store in iCloud including Desktop and Documents using your Apple ID will remain there after you erase an Apple product whether you're performing a clean install and keeping the device or prepping it for resale.
Just make sure you follow these procedures from Apple before selling a device otherwise you'll create a problem in the future for its new owner:
https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201065
I've been trying these features out on two macs for the last couple of days and I think the system is both set up logically and seems to work well. Of course, with cloud systems one error and things could go catastrophically wrong so the system must have had a lot of testing.
But - providing you are aware that you need to setup the 'master' Mac first - then the system works well. My use of two systems is fairly regular: one at home, and one when away. Downloading the the Documents from the main to the secondary Mac seems to work well at keeping that single set of docs in sync. I had to delete my copies of the same doc from the second Mac, which caused a few hours of sync setup before things settled down, but what was going on was clear and I don't think a user should make a mistake unless they are being too hurried.
Because of my workflow I don't tend to have documents open on both computers at the same time, but I did a few tests to see what would happen if that was the case. And what happens is a "Modifications aren't in sync" window arrives, allowing you to choose which version of the doc you want to keep - which thankfully also allows you to keep both docs if you want, in case you have changes in both. It's rather similar to the way Evernote behaves if you have conflicting notes, and rather easier to deal with. You only have to deal with the issue when you open the doc, but I do think large numbers of conflicts would be a real problem, not that that should happen. While I certainly wouldn't recommend it as the best way of keeping projects in sync, even changes to a git repository seemed to transfer quickly and smoothly between the two systems.
I'm happy enough with the syncing and will use it for docs that I don't mind being in the cloud. I have created a second non-Cloud documents folder as well, for things I want to keep local only. As for Time Machine and other backups - I'm going to download the docs to both systems and make sure they feature in both sets of backups. I also rather like the way the existing but not downloaded files are represented in the Finder window - and the way this is achieved by using a hidden file with a .icloud extension. Best not to mess with those files too much, I think.
But - providing you are aware that you need to setup the 'master' Mac first - then the system works well. My use of two systems is fairly regular: one at home, and one when away. Downloading the the Documents from the main to the secondary Mac seems to work well at keeping that single set of docs in sync. I had to delete my copies of the same doc from the second Mac, which caused a few hours of sync setup before things settled down, but what was going on was clear and I don't think a user should make a mistake unless they are being too hurried.
Because of my workflow I don't tend to have documents open on both computers at the same time, but I did a few tests to see what would happen if that was the case. And what happens is a "Modifications aren't in sync" window arrives, allowing you to choose which version of the doc you want to keep - which thankfully also allows you to keep both docs if you want, in case you have changes in both. It's rather similar to the way Evernote behaves if you have conflicting notes, and rather easier to deal with. You only have to deal with the issue when you open the doc, but I do think large numbers of conflicts would be a real problem, not that that should happen. While I certainly wouldn't recommend it as the best way of keeping projects in sync, even changes to a git repository seemed to transfer quickly and smoothly between the two systems.
I'm happy enough with the syncing and will use it for docs that I don't mind being in the cloud. I have created a second non-Cloud documents folder as well, for things I want to keep local only. As for Time Machine and other backups - I'm going to download the docs to both systems and make sure they feature in both sets of backups. I also rather like the way the existing but not downloaded files are represented in the Finder window - and the way this is achieved by using a hidden file with a .icloud extension. Best not to mess with those files too much, I think.
Same here. I moved documents that I did not want in the cloud to an alternate documents folder, and turned on iCloud Desktop and Documents on two Macs. Everything worked as expected.
A.
Last edited:
A view of Setup Assistant:
![iCloudDriveOptions.jpg]()
– How to Upgrade Install macOS Sierra Safely on Your Mac
– Use the Setup Assistant to Finish the macOS Sierra Installation (4 of 4)
– Use the Setup Assistant to Finish the macOS Sierra Installation (4 of 4)
Another view of Setup Assistant.
I tested an upgrade from El Capitan, declined the invitation to use iCloud Keychain, allowed automatic upload of files from the Documents folder and Desktop:
![IMG_20160928_011203.jpg]( "IMG_20160928_011203.jpg")
![IMG_20160928_011254.jpg]( "IMG_20160928_011254.jpg")
No mention of photos or videos, probably because I made decisions long before Sierra.
I tested an upgrade from El Capitan, declined the invitation to use iCloud Keychain, allowed automatic upload of files from the Documents folder and Desktop:
No mention of photos or videos, probably because I made decisions long before Sierra.
I have both a 2014 11" MBA and a 2013 iMac and decided to first upgrade my MBA to Sierra. I was quite ticked off to see that the install moved all of my desktop and document files to iCloud without asking. Thankfully I don't keep many files in those locations on the MBA. I will NOT be upgrading the iMac (my primary system) until Apple provides an option to disable that behavior during install.
See the photographs above, and the the screenshot above that. Setup Assistant, which asks.
Welcome to the Internet Age, where people will believe any romantic fantasy (Night Shift, H2O requirements, people & dinosaurs, etc) despite a complete lack of scientific evidence, but will disbelieve things (evolution, global warming) for which there are mountains of documentation.
/rant
A.
I've noticed in the past that the features for which I'm most excited as an idea, I tend to be most disappointed in the execution. iCloud Photo Library and the revamped Music app both come to mind. How has your experience been with this one? Are you as ecstatic about the end product as you were about the idea?
Uh of course, what is there not to like? It stores your Desktop and Documents folders in iCloud. It doesn't interfere with normal use. Also couldn't be happier with iCloud Photo Library, it does exactly what its supposed to do: Stores all photo and video in the cloud, automatically. Every device can access. Devices with more storage can keep local copies. Devices with less storage can brilliantly optimize and still have access. Could not be better.
I find people typically have their own niche ideas that make very little real world sense, and would adversely affect the experience for 90% of users, are often the ones "unhappy" with perfectly executed features.
Translation: when an implementation fits perfectly with how I do things, it is a perfectly executed feature... and people who disagree do so because they possess very little real world sense.
