Since I started this thread, I might as well post an update about my use of it.
Basically, I broke it in half. On purpose. Having gone back and forth on it for a while I got tired of the feeling that I should use it because it cost me $80, so I figured the only way I would escape the madness was to get rid of it permanently.
The offset was fine with me. What wasn't fine was two things that turned out to be bigger problems than I liked long term.
First of all the auto shutoff feature was just beyond annoying. I'm a teacher, and so my primary use for this was correction various hand-ins, a task that doesn't involve constant stylus use. Finding the thing shut off every time I picked it back up again was just too annoying.
Second was the random power drain. It seems to use power when shut off, so it got to the point where I was changing batteries way too often, finding I had a non-working pen when I needed it, etc. Also, because it randomly cuts in and out during use when low on battery, rather than just working/not working, I found myself erasing half detected letters more often than anything I considered OK.
So, I've gone back to my Wacom Bamboo Duo, and frankly it's a pleasure to use after having used the Script for a while. While not as accurate, the fact I can pick it up and know it's working every single time is just worth more to me.