I picked up one for mine from target for 60% off and couldn't stand it. Water tested it and it was fine. I could see possibly using it on hikes and the beach but I think I'm just going to keep it on a shelf most of the time. There's no way I could stand letting my iPad live in that thing after I've used it without a case for around six months now. It wasn't even really the bulk that killed the experience for me, it was the fact that my mute switch was such a pain to flip (I use it as an orientation lock).