Just jumping in here, but for all the folks with negative views on Apple's AI ambitions, I wonder what product Apple should produce that would indicate they are are not falling behind or leaping frogging ahead? Those ChatBots are cool from OpenAI but what value, outside of entertainment, are they bringing? Sure people are using them to write better or edit their writing (10x more efficient at your job!), "aid" their online test taking, help teachers "catch" students who are submitting AI generated test answers and copy other people's work that was used to train their LLM. But what value is that? Of course, I see the potential of AI and it will potentially be enormously powerful and disruptive to work people do today. So given these challenges, where is the value to the consumer and society (no sarcasm)? Open AI started as non-profit but surprisingly! changed to for profit. The "Godfather of AI" Geoff Hinton left Google becuase he was worried! about the rush into AI without considering it's impact on society. What I see is that the biggest cheerleaders for AI don't neccesarily have your best interests at heart. There are wealthy people hyping and pushing alot of money around into AI and if things go south, well, they'll be fine. I would ask ChatGPT who the likely losers will be in that scenario but I am not sure I need AI to generate that answer.