Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Princess Cake

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 15, 2010
327
256
Cheboygan, MI
It seems like at random a couple times a month Finder will forget the custom settings I've set for viewing. The window size, icon and text size, and even background get reset.

Any ideas? It mostly seems to happen when I use directories on an external HDD... I've done permission repairs, cleaned caches, checked for bad sectors and always the drive comes out tip-top.

finderview.jpg
 
It seems like at random a couple times a month Finder will forget the custom settings I've set for viewing. The window size, icon and text size, and even background get reset.

Any ideas? It mostly seems to happen when I use directories on an external HDD... I've done permission repairs, cleaned caches, checked for bad sectors and always the drive comes out tip-top.

View attachment 947045

It may be that owner:group settings on the external drive — here, “External HD” — are not the same as they may be were it on an internal directory on that particular Mac (i.e., your home directory, such as /Users/nikki/ or whatever you log in with).

If this is the case, it’s possible you may not have owner:group write access to the invisible files inside “External HD” — specifically, the .DS_Store files stored within each directory. They may be set to something like root:wheel or something other than your admin name.

You should be able to verify this on your external drive via Terminal and running a 'cd /Volumes/External\ HD/' (without the quotes) and then 'ls -la' to list what comes up for the invisible .DS_Store file on that main HDD directory (or checking out the same for the sub-directories where you’re having these problems). From the looks of your screencaps, you may have a /Volumes/External\ HD/Movies/ sub-directory.

If the .DS_Store file there is set to something like root:wheel and not something like admin:staff or nikki:nikki or similar, then there are two things you could try:

1) The quick-and-dirty: using Terminal and from that sub-directory where you’re having problems, delete the .DS_Store file with a 'rm .DS_Store' command. (If it says “permission denied”, it may require you to run this command as 'sudo rm .DS_Store' and enter your password). Then, go back to Finder, open that directory, set it up the way you want it, and then run a Cmd-J on that window to make sure that “Always open in icon view” is not selected. Doing this will create a new .DS_Store file whose file permissions should be newly set to your login (and giving you write access).

2) The more thorough: you may want to run a 'sudo chown -R [owner:group] /Volumes/External\ HD/' for that external HDD for all files and directories to share the same owner:group you have for your home directory — with the same read-write-execute (rwx) settings as, say, your home directory. First, enter 'sudo chown -R admin:staff /Voiumes/External\ HD/', let it run to completion (probably a few seconds to a minute or two), and then run a 'sudo chmod -R 775 /Volumes/External\ HD/' and also let it run to completion (775 for rwx access for owner (i.e., admin), rwx access for group (i.e., staff), and rx access for everyone else). This should allow you to change directory settings for any directory on the External HD via Finder, and it should remember those settings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Raging Dufus
It seems like at random a couple times a month Finder will forget the custom settings I've set for viewing. The window size, icon and text size, and even background get reset.

Any ideas? It mostly seems to happen when I use directories on an external HDD... I've done permission repairs, cleaned caches, checked for bad sectors and always the drive comes out tip-top.

View attachment 947045

Any success/failure?
 

Wowfunhappy

macrumors 68000
Mar 12, 2019
1,616
1,991
...this isn't helpful at all, but hasn't Finder just always been this way? I think I've run into this for as long as I've been using OS X.

It's a shame too, because it renders pointless things like that super cool movie folder setup you have.
 

Princess Cake

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 15, 2010
327
256
Cheboygan, MI
Not gonna lie, B S Magnet... I felt like a complete idiot reading your post and can barely tell what you're suggesting I try to do :/

I did seem to fix the problem though. I disabled "Always open in icon view" and I haven't had the view settings mess up in over a month. Annoying how often the folder loads in list view (I switch between views a lot) but its better than having to re-do all my settings or go into Time Machine and restore the .DS file from before it exploded.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.