Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
French Regulator to Probe Apple's Upcoming Anti-Tracking Feature [Updated]
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I thought Europeans were all about protecting consumer privacy? WTF France?
Exactly! I guess it’s easier to just spit out BS in these days where immediate reaction prevails over thinking.
So, despite everything we can reed here, the only thing the French are doing is making sure Apple applies the same rules to itself. What a disgrace. ?
The move by Apple is definitely anti-competitive. It is anti-competitive in that it skews the advantage to the consumer against the corporation, corporations who are acquiring their raw material (consumer data) without consumer's explicit consent.
A political one where anyone or any organization with enough money or influence can push for any ridiculous policy... good or bad for citizens... doesn’t matter so long as it doesn’t hurt their political career.
Don't they have better things to do? The question governments should be asking is, how is it allowed that companies are allowed to mine data about what I do, eat, drink, and so on ...?
It is almost like they have a hidden camera in my home aimed at my computer screen without consent, which doesn't sound very legal to me.
And now they are crying because Apple puts a stop to it?
It is almost like they have a hidden camera in my home aimed at my computer screen without consent, which doesn't sound very legal to me.
And now they are crying because Apple puts a stop to it?
If Apple is doing what they say they're doing by applying all the same rules to itself, then it has nothing to worry about.
I do think the way the question is being asked implies only good or bad akin to "would you like to die a terrible death where all your skin falls off in scaley peices or not"
A more balanced question could be:
"would you like app tracking enabled to allow third parties to personalise content for you?"
"would you like to disable app tracking to limit personalised content?
A more balanced question could be:
"would you like app tracking enabled to allow third parties to personalise content for you?"
"would you like to disable app tracking to limit personalised content?
Apple is definitely in the advertising business, although it's not its core business like e.g. Google.
I don't want to be tracked so much. I understand what Apple is doing isn't going to stop us all being tracked, but at least this will reduce it happening on our Apple devices. If you want to allow companies to track you, then opt in. No one should be forced into being tracked, give us choice!
It'll be great if apple come out looking clean from this, my trust in them will be elevated.
It's hard to believe that anyone would advocate for tracking, snooping and profiting from stuff you do in your personal time. Well, except governments and advertisers.
I’m never not gonna support probes into apples business practices. Best case it comes out saying nope, everything’s fine here. Or other best case (for actual customers) they find something wrong and make apple correct it. For customers it’s win win
It’s not even the spying by the App you are actually using. It’s the sharing and selling to 3rd parties and data brokers. So, I might accept tracking from one company because I know them, but they choose to give it to a 3rd party with unknown shady associations. This info then becomes the center of phishing campaigns where they know where you’ve been and who you do business with. Not good at all.
Well, for the govt to "probe" features that has a lot of impact does seem like the right thing to do, especially to make sure Apple also apply some of its rules to itself so as not to give itself an edge..
It's obvious to us techies that this feature is a good thing so if they decide against it then I'll join all y'all in your righteous indignation. Until then it's just the regulators trying to understand what ramifications it has for Apple and other businesses. They might have received complaints about it and it's their job to investigate, hopefully without bias.
Both parties can benefit. Apple will love the government approved sticker for sure. Marketing gold.
Edit: exactly as expected, Apple is welcoming the investigation.
Last edited:
True.The fact that the rest don’t like France is covered in the famous Trillion Dollar episode of the Simpsons.
We don’t know the findings yet but:
1. iOS 14 won’t ban tracking.
2. Apple asks you on installation and activation about tracking, even for diagnostic purposes, and you can opt out. You don’t need iCloud or a paid account to use the iPhone, and you can limit tracking in every aspect of the OS, though some features won’t work without some form of location services. But that info isn’t mined and sold anyway.
And now the article has been updated with a statement from Apple thanking France but everyone here continues to read only the title. This is beyond hilarious ? Internet in a nutshell.