Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LinMac

macrumors 65816
Oct 28, 2007
1,197
13
0.

Short version: Too expensive.

Long version: Rentals are a very common thing these days thanks to stores like Blockbuster that pioneered the idea of allowing people to rent videos.

A simple cost comparison will show why the AppleTV rentals are not a good value compared to Redbox or Netflix both of which seem to have higher overhead than Apple does with their medialess distribution.

Movies:

Redbox: $1 per day
Netflix: Roughly $1 - 2 per DVD depending on factors such as time to view and speed of U.S. Mail
AppleTV: $2.99 - $3.99 for older movies / $3.99 - $4.99 for new releases

Take into account the restrictions placed on them (24 hour viewing limit is a deal breaker) and it isn't surprising to see people aren't exactly abandoning their Netflix accounts.

I understand that there is a difference in time to receiving the content, but the services are still competitors so I believe it is a valid comparison.

TV shows:

This is where I really think the pricing is a joke.

Netflix: Roughly $1 - 2 per DVD depending on factors such as time to view and speed of U.S. Mail.

Each DVD will contain 3 - 6 episodes of a TV show with an average of 4 (from my experience). This translates to roughly $0.30 - $0.60 per episode via DVD.

AppleTV: $1.99 per episode with more for "premium" content from HBO.

The pricing of the content on the various services such as Unbox or Apple's iTunes will have to come down in price to reach a point where the mass market will buy it as an alternative to cable. It might be a good supplement to cable if you miss an episode of a show, but there is also competition from websites such as Hulu or the omnipresent option of Bittorrent.
 

mark34

macrumors 6502a
May 18, 2006
643
161
I have probably rented 10 to 15, all HD. The Kingdom was really good. Slightly dull center channel output, but all other channels excellent and picture quality really quite good. No Country for Old Men... uh, well cant decide if I liked it, but the quality was good.

All have been watchable in less less than 60 seconds from pressing buy, none has had even a stutter.

Brilliant execution in my opinion. Bring on more HD movies. Also, would be nice if HD movies had HD previews. The trailers are fun also. I usually watch a couple before a movie. The HD quaility of the HD trailers is not as good as HD movie rentals. Most of the HD trailers appear a little washed out to me.

What a cool device, truly. Not the end all be all....

I also love that you can subscribe directly to .mac web galleries. perfect.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.