Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

flaubert

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jun 16, 2015
469
184
Portland, Oregon
Hi, I’m thinking of picking up a spare Mac Pro 5,1 to have on hand for parts in case anything goes south with my current single-processor 5,1. My current Mac Pro is a true 2010 Mac Pro 5,1 so I would like the spare to be the same, for maximum compatibility. However, it can be tricky to spot an upgraded 4,1, correct? I seem to recall that once you upgrade the firmware it identifies as a 5,1. Is there an easy, reliable way to confirm that a given machine is a 5,1 2010 hardware model without getting deep into pulling off heatsinks to look at processors, etc? I know that the 4,1 models shipped with GT 120 graphics cards, but I was hoping that there was a field in system report that I could inspect or have a prospective seller send me a snapshot of. Thanks for your help.

Kurt
 

tsialex

Contributor
Jun 13, 2016
13,033
13,261
Hi, I’m thinking of picking up a spare Mac Pro 5,1 to have on hand for parts in case anything goes south with my current single-processor 5,1. My current Mac Pro is a true 2010 Mac Pro 5,1 so I would like the spare to be the same, for maximum compatibility. However, it can be tricky to spot an upgraded 4,1, correct? I seem to recall that once you upgrade the firmware it identifies as a 5,1. Is there an easy, reliable way to confirm that a given machine is a 5,1 2010 hardware model without getting deep into pulling off heatsinks to look at processors, etc? I know that the 4,1 models shipped with GT 120 graphics cards, but I was hoping that there was a field in system report that I could inspect or have a prospective seller send me a snapshot of. Thanks for your help.

Kurt
Yes, there are. About This Mac > System Report > Hardware Overview > SMC Version:

MP4,1>5,1 = 1.39f5
MP5,1 = 1.39f11

Screen Shot 2019-05-17 at 21.45.03.png


SMC versions are immutable. You can fake a case, fake a serial number, even fake a BootROM, but you can't change the SMC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kohlson

mrtang42

macrumors member
Apr 19, 2019
73
18
Yes, there are. About This Mac > System Report > Hardware Overview > SMC Version:

MP4,1>5,1 = 1.39f5
MP5,1 = 1.39f11

View attachment 837652

SMC versions are immutable. You can fake a case, fake a serial number, even fake a BootROM, but you can't change the SMC.
You actually can move a 5,1 SMC chip to a 4,1 motherboard by soldering. Someone has done this before.
 

tsialex

Contributor
Jun 13, 2016
13,033
13,261
You actually can move a 5,1 SMC chip to a 4,1 motherboard by soldering. Someone has done this before.
Yes, but this has to be professionally made with equipment that that costs over 4 digits, to replace a TCQFP-144 with fine pitch it's not something for the usual eBay/Craigslist faker. The costs of supplies alone make this anti-economical for backplanes and single CPU trays, but can be valid for dual CPU trays.

You can always check the MLB/LBSN label and use the 4 last digits (read about refurbished below) to identify exactly the backplane:

MP51 - LBSN_MLB - SPI.jpeg
MP51 - LBSN_MLB.jpeg


early-2009: 1LTB, 1LTC, BH7A, DCVKA?

DCVKA? are the last 6 digits for 17 digits refurbished boards, the last digit is variable. Examples: DCVKAC, DCVKA6, DCVKAV, DCVKA9​

mid-2010 & mid-2012: BH9A, BH9B
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.