Hey MR Crew,
I am eligible for an interest-free computer loan via my employer, and I want the system to pull double-duty: to assist me with work-related tasks from home (which are relatively rare and could be done on a Chromebook), and for the new system to become the centerpiece of my new project recording studio. My budget could allow for an entry-level Mac Studio, a near-entry level 14" MBP, or a nicely-spec'd Macbook Air M2.
Since I want to have the ability to do remote recording, the Mac Studio isn't at the top of my list (although with a portable monitor, keyboard, and hard shell case, I COULD actually do remote recordings with one--it just wouldn't be all that convenient). That leaves the other two options.
Another criterion that matters to me is 100% silent operation, and the MBA delivers on that. Yes, I know one has to really bog an MBP down with CPU and/or GPU tasks in order to get the fans to even spin up at all, let alone to audible levels, but it would be something I would prefer to avoid.
So I am leaning heavily toward an MBA M2 with 8-core CPU/8-core GPU (which is touted to run cooler than the 10-GPU version), 24 GB RAM and 2 TB storage. With an education discount, that'll come in at $2,219. Since MBA's cannot be upgraded later, going with the biggest RAM and storage options makes sense to me. I plan on using big Superior Drummer libraries for drum sounds, and even some orchestral libraries on rare occasions, and I'm hoping 24 GB (the max I can order) will facilitate my future needs in this regard. 2 TB of storage is really just another bit of future-proofing, in that, generally speaking, the bigger SSDs are the faster they are, and the longer they last (at least that's my current understanding).
The one Achilles's Heel of the MBA M2 is, of course heat dissipation under load. Since I value fanless silence, I am wondering if anyone here at MR has suggestions for ways to wick heat away from the bottom of an MBA M2 that are 100% passive and silent. I already have an aluminum stand to elevate it off the desktop, allow room air to circulate better, and possibly serve as a heat sink itself. Are there any other ways I could pull heat from the chip? FWIW, I DON'T want to do the MaxTech thermal pad mod, as it has the potential to shorten battery life over time.
Would it make sense to apply a small square of thermal pad to my aluminum stand, precisely under where the processor sits, that could draw heat from the MBA chassis over to my aluminum stand? I would have to leave the backing plastic on the top side of the pad so that I can move the MBA on and off the stand at will. Do thermal pads still work when that backing is left on one side?
I suppose, when mixing down a huge project, I could go old-school and toss an ice-pack under the stand to keep it frigid cold. I mean, 90% of the time Logic running alone isn't going to push the MBA M2 anywhere near its thermal limits, so I'm only contemplating heat mitigation under extreme circumstances.
I would welcome any reflections you might have on ANY of this. I appreciate the real-world wisdom and insights here @ MR.
Thanks, Bart
I am eligible for an interest-free computer loan via my employer, and I want the system to pull double-duty: to assist me with work-related tasks from home (which are relatively rare and could be done on a Chromebook), and for the new system to become the centerpiece of my new project recording studio. My budget could allow for an entry-level Mac Studio, a near-entry level 14" MBP, or a nicely-spec'd Macbook Air M2.
Since I want to have the ability to do remote recording, the Mac Studio isn't at the top of my list (although with a portable monitor, keyboard, and hard shell case, I COULD actually do remote recordings with one--it just wouldn't be all that convenient). That leaves the other two options.
Another criterion that matters to me is 100% silent operation, and the MBA delivers on that. Yes, I know one has to really bog an MBP down with CPU and/or GPU tasks in order to get the fans to even spin up at all, let alone to audible levels, but it would be something I would prefer to avoid.
So I am leaning heavily toward an MBA M2 with 8-core CPU/8-core GPU (which is touted to run cooler than the 10-GPU version), 24 GB RAM and 2 TB storage. With an education discount, that'll come in at $2,219. Since MBA's cannot be upgraded later, going with the biggest RAM and storage options makes sense to me. I plan on using big Superior Drummer libraries for drum sounds, and even some orchestral libraries on rare occasions, and I'm hoping 24 GB (the max I can order) will facilitate my future needs in this regard. 2 TB of storage is really just another bit of future-proofing, in that, generally speaking, the bigger SSDs are the faster they are, and the longer they last (at least that's my current understanding).
The one Achilles's Heel of the MBA M2 is, of course heat dissipation under load. Since I value fanless silence, I am wondering if anyone here at MR has suggestions for ways to wick heat away from the bottom of an MBA M2 that are 100% passive and silent. I already have an aluminum stand to elevate it off the desktop, allow room air to circulate better, and possibly serve as a heat sink itself. Are there any other ways I could pull heat from the chip? FWIW, I DON'T want to do the MaxTech thermal pad mod, as it has the potential to shorten battery life over time.
Would it make sense to apply a small square of thermal pad to my aluminum stand, precisely under where the processor sits, that could draw heat from the MBA chassis over to my aluminum stand? I would have to leave the backing plastic on the top side of the pad so that I can move the MBA on and off the stand at will. Do thermal pads still work when that backing is left on one side?
I suppose, when mixing down a huge project, I could go old-school and toss an ice-pack under the stand to keep it frigid cold. I mean, 90% of the time Logic running alone isn't going to push the MBA M2 anywhere near its thermal limits, so I'm only contemplating heat mitigation under extreme circumstances.
I would welcome any reflections you might have on ANY of this. I appreciate the real-world wisdom and insights here @ MR.
Thanks, Bart