CmdrLaForge said:
Hi guys,
I am starting to finalize my little home brew studio. What I do is very simple recording of me playing guitar while singing, adding some drums, bass, rhythm, synth mixing it and voila - I made myself a song.
What I already have is a G4 iBook 1,42 GHz, 1.5gig RAM. Focusrite Saffire Interface, two condensor Mics - RODE NT3
I worked with Garageband2 and like it, but I want a more pro app. Now here comes my question. I can afford:
- Logic Express
- Ableton Live 5
- Motu Digital Performer
- Cubase SX (comes with the Saffire)
I like to use it for recording, mixing and mastering. What do you guys suggest?
Thanks for any feedback
Cheers
LaForge
There is no ONE piece of software for all these. Recording is pretty basic, in anything, QT 7 has an option to record, wow! Mixing is, well, moving volumes around, so you can get near 0db & not go over.... EQ etc. and choose where in the stereo image to put everything (pan)...
Mastering, is say on a CD, where you then make sure it's mixed OK, and final tweaking EQ, compression, and making the levels super HOT. ( If you notice a 1978 recording on say an iPod, then a newer song comes on REALLY LOUD - but volume didn't change - this is compression/ limiting - commercials on TV do this, Laws make volume change illegal - so they compress it so it seems louder, while legally being within the law....the Movie needs very quiet vs. loud to build drama, etc.
If your recording is inaudible between two other tracks ( volume unchanged) it sounds unprofessional, and frankly, can't be heard without running over and turning up volume.
This particular task, Mastering, I have always used Peak, and Waves +L1 Sonic Maximizer / Limiter. Never Normalize!!!
I'm trying to understand what you want/ need, and since you mention no MIDI, or anything, I'd like to suggest Deck 3.5 & Peak ( I get LE versions of these ALL THE TIME! Limited Edition? Lame Edition? ???) So FREE or close to it should be an option - and 30 day trial of course you can start now free....enter serial & you're good ( Google search may yield one ;-)
My only reservation is Tiger & various other issues, had some problems ( but I presume that's hammered out in recent updates -they are great about telling you if they have a bug, and fixing it quick!) Also, since I have every plug in ever, VST, like 2400? I've had to stay in OS 9 with it, and all those plugs were classic only ( so I'd boot into 9 - but I can't anymore 17" PB -sigh- )
Anyway, it offers what you want in Mix, Master, statement - you can assign a bus - say compress, normalize (don't!), and assign those to ALL tracks ( also you can edit a track - Peak pops up - Use Limiter, cut, paste, etc. ) Then it has another Output with 4 inserts - so you can add 4 stereo FX on the last stage before output.
( Like any program using Core Audio - this can also do surround sound, 32 bit 10,000KHz Audio, etc. )
I just noticed someone suggested Pro Tools. What a useless program! But there is a PT FREE which is free, download it & try it..... Yeah it has all the MIDI abilities of a preschool learning disability - maybe in a decade they'll put in more? )
Logic is complex! It's set up to be a MIDI Audio Loop FX thing - but Apple & Logic = GB 2 So getting better Virtual instruments & all - you'd probably like it a lot.....
Deck, like Pro Tools, pretty much is a big tape recorder. But, you can assign say 24 tracks to a bus with EQ / Compression/ Reverb/ & Noise Gate - then set up various others.....but you know, directions are hit RECORD button to record, stop, all like a tape recorder - so less Manual reading....cheap....but powerful.....
If you do have time ( like years!) Logic is powerful, but not intuitive, like Office, you can find all sorts of stuff in it, but how many will you use? Logic has the edge, when OS Updates, or Macintels ship - Only Logic has had a chance to fix bugs the whole time it's been worked on - so even though I hate it's UI - it has all the advantages - unless time, money, etc. are issues...
I hope this helps, not positive what you're trying to do here.... Another option anyway,
Good Luck!
L.T.