I really like the small size of my old iPod Shuffle, and it is absolutely criminal that Apple has never made a new version of the Shuffle or Nano with compatibility with Apple Music. I understand the anti-piracy thing, but I don't buy at all that being a barrier to doing this. I am not a highly-paid Apple hardware/software engineer, and I can imagine ways this could work. The iPod could be designed with a minimal WiFi capability; the user would use a PC/Mac running iTunes to set up the Shuffle's WiFi, then and Apple Music songs loaded on the device would play as long as the Shuffle was able to "phone home" once a day.