The N64 was a failure - not in the quality of some of its titles but in this sense.
Nintendo was the leader of the pack. It had outsold it's competitor Sega and others like Atari.
Yet due to complacency and it's insistence on sticking to a format that whilst allowing some years of copy protection and instant loading, hindered a lot of the development community who were woooed by the new kid on the block.
Sony came in - the naughty little upstart. "What did it know about gaming consoles ?" Nintendo laughed... But in the end it's marketing, new maturer format, and ability to attract developers who were looking for new ways of moving their games on - but hindered by size restrictions / cost of cartridge based medium.
In the space of 1 generation of consoles... Nintendo had lost the top spot in regards to home consoles.
That indeed can be seen as a massive failure. And it goes to show what happens when you become complacent in a marketplace. You dont decide what the consumer buys - the consumer does.
This was re-inforced with the incredible failure of the virtual boy. A sign that lessons were still being learned.
In many ways if it had not been for the mammoth success of the gameboy handhelds - Nintendo may not be with us now. Another possible Sega. Thankfully they did and they are still here.
Now...
However if we look at today.... That situation has almost gone the direct opposite, and the once jumpy little upstart 'Sony' who took on and became the giant of home consoles - is now looking a little sad.
It too has become complacent. It too said 'you will buy' dictate methodology rather than listening to what the consumers actually want.
And now it finds itself in the unenviable task of being in current 'third place'
If in 5 years the PS3 is still bottom of the sales pile, I'm sure it too in 10 years time will be seen as a 'failure'....
But....
Nintendo do need to get those bloody games out. The games that attract as much enthusiasm as Wii Sports. I mean where is Wii Sports 2 ? Why are games like BrainAge taking SO long to come out of the burner. These are not overly complex games, but they are the games that have attracted 'new audiences' - the very same new audiences who for the last 8 months have been criminally ignored.
And as for releasing PAL versions 6 or months later. I question if they really understand the European market, especially in 2007, when we are used to near identical cinema / dvd / cd releases. When the age of waiting for stuff has been done away with thanks to the digital medium.
Nintendo have done an amazing job getting the Wii into peoples homes. They have done a god damn awful job so far of following that up.
Apart from gamers - I know very few of the original people who bought the Wii at christmas for wii sports fun - who are still using the machine. It has in many ways become the Breville Sandwich Toaster, every home has one.... but who's using them ?
So complacency is still there.
A follow up to a free 'demo' which is still the pinacle of 'wii gaming' is still not here. That is BAD in anyones books.
-----
Only time will tell.