I’m not an audiophile by any means and I get what you’re saying, however I, for one, would be extremely shocked if Apple would sell a product for $200 bucks cheaper that’s just as good, half the size and a fraction of the weight. May as well just kill the full sized HomePod right now.
Compared to the market, the HomePod mini is way more competitive (price wise) than the HomePod. So it may indeed make business sense for Apple to focus on the smaller version and axe the big one, once supplies have dried up.
Whether it’s possible or not for the audio quality in the Mini to be as good as the full size using software sorcery, I don’t even think Apple would unleash that power. They’d be cannibalizing sales from a more expensive product that’s already not moving many units. From a business standpoint, there should be a discernible difference between the two. The price difference alone is what makes me think the Mini will be inferior in terms of sound. Once again, speculating here but we shall see in a few short weeks.
With the HomePod, Apple has demonstrated an amazing long time of good will for a product not meeting their expectations.
The “smart speaker” market did not accept the price point (and also Siri is still lacking) and the audiophile folks did not like the audio (I would subscribe to the notion that it has a bit much bass) and rather went for a full-fledged HiFi rig or took the Echo Studio instead. And many people disliked the lock in to AppleMusic and lack of ports.
But Apple was between a rock and a hard place: Leaving the Smart speaker market to the competition would not have been a wise move. So the HomePod had to stay (and with Apple-typical stubbornness they could not lower the price).
With the HomePod mini, Apple has a better suited product available for the mass market. So now is the first time they could actually call it a day and cancel the first gen HomePod altogether. Or they keep it available as competitor to higher quality smart speakers like the Echo Studio. After all, they now have nearly something like a lineup in the Smart speaker world.
Really looking forward to the reviews and planning to replace the Echo Dot’s in my house.