TP-Link Deco S4 mesh router. But I think there is a newer model. During covid when everyone's internet was hammered -- This thing helped so much
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Looking for a good router to potentially replace my eero (based on problems I've had with it)
- Thread starter RoboCop001
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I got a 1Gig connection at home and I believe there is a certain threshold of network speed below which you are not able to see if something is actually faster then anything else. I mean, Netflix starts instantly on my Toshiba TV connected thorough wifi, even F1TV which uses adaptive codec displays only a couple of frames in lowres for a fraction of a second and then goes HD. On the other hand, I upload mostly to my clients storage using VPN, so it is slow by nature. OK, it takes about 3 minutes to put a full ISO image of Ubuntu server (1.5 gigabytes) onto ESXi storage of a client of mine with a VPN connection. Not exactly slow, methinks.
Measure your current network speeds, a couple of times, with different servers, using a wired connection to the router. Perhaps measure it to the location of your uploads? Ask the admin if he's able to set up an iperf3 server temporarily. If you are anything below 600mbps average, you may be well served with a DR.
May take a look at their routers, thanks. Never really thought about trying TP-Link, does the app let you assign certain times of the day when certain devices can access the internet?
Good to know! I haven't done a wired speed test, but my service is rated 75Mbps down and 10Mbps up. Generally I get around 70 down and 10 up (wireless).
That's definitely under 600 hahah. But everything runs well. I can download large files and stream things at the same time without noticeable quality/speed loss. Plus my TV is only 1080p, so I'm sure that helps.
While a great piece of kit (I run a UDM Pro at home) the UDM Pro SE is an overkill for a "just works" home environment IMHO. And it calls for a server rack
We're talking router, the Unifi Apps (video surveillance etc) are an added bonus in this case. My observations in regards of the DR are ~750 Mbps with all security turned to the max. Admittedly, it took a couple of firmware upgrades to reach that, albeit it is said to be resolved now. For $199 it is still one of the best options on the market.
Great point about Wifi6 in Dream Machine, but apart from local transfers I do not notice any improvement with Wifi6 compared to 802.11ac. The distance to the AP is crucial in this case.
You can stick it on a shelf if you want, don’t need a server rack, I’ve seen some just put them on tops of side tables etc and even plonk an access point just on top of it lol. I still don’t think the UDR is a good option having had one, it just seems way underpowered especially compared to the standard UDM. I think an Alien may be better in that case, but the UDR will look a lot better if it’s in plain sight.
Last edited:
Thanks for your insight. I'll try to do a thorough comparison of the UDM, UDR, and Alien. I was leaning more heavily towards an Alien, though yeah... does seem like overkill for my needs at first glance.
I cuss at Spectrum, and wait.
Sometimes I reboot the modem...but zero interactions are needed for either the router or APs.
Hahah well that would be one less thing for me to cuss at! I end up cussing more at the eero than the provider because the eero is just dumb.
Perfect 😂🤣 I never even knew those existed lol. Imagine it being in your living room with constant fans whirring away!LackRack - Eth0Wiki
wiki.eth0.nl
No problem. For me I think I will consider the Alien Mesh system, the TP Link Deco XE75 and the new Google Mesh system when it's out, and any new Amplifi system that comes out if it's this year, I have not heard anything about any new models though.
I'm basically avoiding another eero because of my current experience with it. What are you using now? I haven't decided on a purchase yet.
What is that router Wi-Fi, B or N on your device? Some voters might have the secondary frequency that your devices need!
I don't have a need for a mesh, so I use a Netgate for a firewall and a Google Nest for WiFi. It covers two 1800 sq ft floors with ease. If I needed mesh, I would use the Google Nest as the router, as it cannot do mesh if it's not doing routing (poor choice Google). I've been really happy with it, though, despite that one limitation.
I don't know of a consumer-purchased router or WAP that won't allow you to customize the WiFi SSID and password.
You're asking the wrong person. I was commenting that most, if not all, routers and WAPs will downgrade to 802.11b if needed. I think you're replying to @Elmo1938 .
es because if these devices only run B is SOL in todays world with such older devices! Now your best bet is to turn of NAT in your old router and get a new Wi-Fi 6 wires router and if you turn of NSAT then you can still use it to power such older equipment!