What Garmin did you have? How would you compare them?
I know you're not talking to me, but I have a perspective that I think you'd like to hear.
I've had a Series 0 SB SS since 2015. I wanted to try something new earlier in 2019. I loved the idea of a rugged smartwatch that you could do all kinds of activity with, and charge every several days, so I purchased a Garmin Fenix 5X.
Went to test it out on the elliptical. Got a wildly different number than the machine gave me. Thought maybe I had something configured wrong on the watch. Went and did it again; same result. Researched online, and there were similar complaints. I also came across the suggestion that the elliptical app that was developed by Garmin wasn't that accurate and to use one of the add-on elliptical apps. I go check, it's a subscription, like $5 a year. $5 is nothing, so I say okay. I go again. It's still pretty inaccurate. I can't find anything in the manual that would address why, and this is after reading through it like the 5th time to address the issue.
Had the same issue on the treadmill.
My Series 0 matched the numbers on the machine every time or came very close.
Also, it bothered me that you couldn't access your playlists on your phone, from your watch. You could press play, pause, fast forward or rewind, but you couldn't select a playlist to play from. Apparently they decided to include that feature in the next model up, as a selling point. Imagine that, holding onto a software tweak like playlist integration and using it to inspire people to purchase the model that costs $100 more.
I rarely return anything but I just couldn't keep it. A fitness-focused watch that didn't seem to accurately analyze the exercise I was doing and had limited features vs an apple watch, which I already knew had great accuracy, and plenty of other uses. Both were $500+.
Returned it and didn't want to buy the Series 4, so I went back to the Series 0. Bought the Series 5 a little while ago.
I had criticisms for Apple but sometimes you decide to go somewhere else and realize what you took for granted before isn’t guaranteed.