Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Where are the killer cases?
- Thread starter mcdj
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It's just some egomaniac "entrepreneur" who's trying to pre-sell a case he hasn't even produced, emblazoned with an ugly giant logo. He's sniffed around here trying to drum up interest for it, and gets shut down by the mods every time. Don't bother.
Yeah it is. Oh well. Too bad. But like I said, there's already at least one thread to merely tell the world what case you have. This is not that thread, unless you're unveiling a previously unseen potential killer case. The Belkin Grip Vue has been discussed ad nauseum, and given the relatively short flash it generated in discussions, I think it's safe to say it doesn't qualify as a killer case, in the vein of the InCase Slider.
I feel the same way... I've been searching for the perfect case since a week before 3G launch! LOL
It's hard to beat the Apple case functionality... However, as we all know the thing attracts dust and scuffs like there is no tomorrow.
I tried the Yoobao. Problem with that one was the smell (ew), and it's just a bit too thick for my liking. I cant clip my pogo stylus to it. It doesn't stay as firmly in typing position as it should. It gets in the way around the edges of the iPad just enough to be annoying.
The Dodo was the one I was going to go for... However, I just don't think the typing position is elevated enough. I even wish the Apple case was elevated just a tad more. That was one thing I DID like about the Yoobao.
My husband has an Incase knockoff... He likes it but doesn't love it... And it doesn't really stay locked into any but the lowest tilt unless its on a table. It's just not great for laps.
If Apple would just make its case with a smoother exterior, one that is easier to clean and doesn't attract scuffs like a chalkboard, they'd have an even harder product to keep in stock - and the ultimate case!
It's hard to beat the Apple case functionality... However, as we all know the thing attracts dust and scuffs like there is no tomorrow.
I tried the Yoobao. Problem with that one was the smell (ew), and it's just a bit too thick for my liking. I cant clip my pogo stylus to it. It doesn't stay as firmly in typing position as it should. It gets in the way around the edges of the iPad just enough to be annoying.
The Dodo was the one I was going to go for... However, I just don't think the typing position is elevated enough. I even wish the Apple case was elevated just a tad more. That was one thing I DID like about the Yoobao.
My husband has an Incase knockoff... He likes it but doesn't love it... And it doesn't really stay locked into any but the lowest tilt unless its on a table. It's just not great for laps.
If Apple would just make its case with a smoother exterior, one that is easier to clean and doesn't attract scuffs like a chalkboard, they'd have an even harder product to keep in stock - and the ultimate case!
Aren't these killer?![MxeeI.jpg]()
There, I fixed your image.
As far as "killer" goes...are they wildly popular, on par with the popularity of the Incase Slider for iPhone, or do they offer a totally unique fit/function that separates them from the pack? You tell me. To me they look like a run of the mill textured/patterned back shell, no different than any of the other 10,000 back shells available on ebay.
I found a link to a review of the piel frama vs the size of the a poke case. It looks like it is a bit heavy and thick for my use -- too bad as it looks beautiful!
I have not seen Oberon mentioned here yet but they do beautiful work. I had one for my Kindle, they are a little on the heavy side for me. Still, really nice and very different from what else is out there. I am so sick of all the black!
![5885.jpg]()
Ooooooo. Beautiful! I can't decide which one to get.
i agree about the lack of cases out there. Usually i can find something that I like, but I find myself making concessions. That is too bad really. The problem with concessions is that I end up finding something else that is closer to the case I actually want - and thus...I spend more money. That is too bad really.
I am looking into the non traditional companies now since the main front runners aren't cutting it. Actually looking at ebay and etsy. Some nice offerings there.
I am looking into the non traditional companies now since the main front runners aren't cutting it. Actually looking at ebay and etsy. Some nice offerings there.
Agreed, but I have come to believe there will be no perfect case. There are so many features to have or not have. Most cases either try to meet too few and are lackluster and many others promise so much but are bulky and obnoxious. I expect plenty of "killer cases" by the time 2G comes around.
I have very high expectations for iSkin's new iPad case that should be coming out any day now.. They took their time that's for sure.
Upcoming Otterbox Defender
This case has a defined audience, but it looks like they put the time and effort into it's design. I eagerly await it's release.
![apl2-ipad1-20-c4otr.jpg]()
![apl2-ipad1-20-c4otr.1.jpg]()
![apl2-ipad1-20-c4otr.2.jpg]()
![apl2-ipad1-20-c4otr.3.jpg]()
This case has a defined audience, but it looks like they put the time and effort into it's design. I eagerly await it's release.
I think he was referring to the dodo case, more than the Belkin. I would consider the dodo case a killer case.
And being nice to people is a good thing, think about it.
To give you an idea, the case adds about the same thickness of the iPad itself. It weighs 300 grams (10.58 oz.) according to the PF website. Subjectively, it never seemed thick or heavy to me, but naturally it is going to be a matter of individual sensitivity. If you like its looks, their customer service is fantastic, and I bet if you emailed Angelina she'd agree that you could return it if you're unhappy. I think PF would be pretty confident that once you have it on your iPad you'll never let it go.
The Dodo case is nice, but it is lacking features, and while that isn't necessarily a bad thing, the $50 price tag is a red herring. It costs $65 with shipping and tax, then you have to wait a month and a half to get one. I love moleskins, dodos, and everything, but I don't think I can stomach it.
I ordered a marware eco-vue, but it is backordered so I have time to cancel and go with something else. I think for $40 the price is OK, but I really think I can do better, with all the people complaining about the thing falling apart after two weeks.
I ordered a marware eco-vue, but it is backordered so I have time to cancel and go with something else. I think for $40 the price is OK, but I really think I can do better, with all the people complaining about the thing falling apart after two weeks.
I have an eco vue I am about to return/sell. PM if you want it.
Anyways the dodo case - its just a book cover isn't it? Recovered and fitted with a bamboo holder? I don't see why it costs so much.
Oh yeah, it is handmade and coming out of SF. I personally like mine for the rugged intellectual look. It's made of buffalo leather.
Anyways the dodo case - its just a book cover isn't it? Recovered and fitted with a bamboo holder? I don't see why it costs so much.
Oh yeah, it is handmade and coming out of SF. I personally like mine for the rugged intellectual look. It's made of buffalo leather.
Attachments
My perfect case would be a combo of a tpu case and a folio that was capable of multiple viewing angles including ones for typing and ones for video viewing with some in between.
Or something like the apple/chinao cases but with more viewing angles. Mostly I just want something that covers all of the corners and sides very well and also offers multiple viewing angles...preferably without being insanely bulky and without covering too much bezel.
Or something like the apple/chinao cases but with more viewing angles. Mostly I just want something that covers all of the corners and sides very well and also offers multiple viewing angles...preferably without being insanely bulky and without covering too much bezel.
I know the prices are obscene but I don't think you can beat the Vaja cases.
The ivolution case is the best "Back cover" style case and they do versions with a snap on front cover for screen protection. The Agenda 2 appears to be the perfect folio style case with a typing position out there (Some prefer the Agenda 1 though).
Both have fantastic quality leather, look great and, crucially, do not cover the front edges of the iPad like many cases do.
I personally have the Special Edition Mamut Suela Ivolution Top style case. I went through 5 cases prior to getting it and I just wish I hadnt wasted my time on cheaper but lesser quality cases. It looks great, feels awesome to hold and after using it for a month shows no signs of wear or tear.
The cheaper cases all have some killer flaw - whether it being dust magnet materials (Like the Apple case, the Chinao interior and the Cyber Acoustics folio), lame typing angles for the folio style cases (Hello Piel Frama), cheap plastic grips to hold in the iPad (Like the Yoobau slim). Some of these may seem relatively minor but the point is that the Vaja's seem to be the only cases that I have seen where I can't see a bad thing about them.
Yes the waiting time for them to be made is an issue however even the Agenda 2's now have certain colours in stock.
I know this sounds like a Vaja love fest but seriously I have tried loads of cases and nothing tops Vaja.
The ivolution case is the best "Back cover" style case and they do versions with a snap on front cover for screen protection. The Agenda 2 appears to be the perfect folio style case with a typing position out there (Some prefer the Agenda 1 though).
Both have fantastic quality leather, look great and, crucially, do not cover the front edges of the iPad like many cases do.
I personally have the Special Edition Mamut Suela Ivolution Top style case. I went through 5 cases prior to getting it and I just wish I hadnt wasted my time on cheaper but lesser quality cases. It looks great, feels awesome to hold and after using it for a month shows no signs of wear or tear.
The cheaper cases all have some killer flaw - whether it being dust magnet materials (Like the Apple case, the Chinao interior and the Cyber Acoustics folio), lame typing angles for the folio style cases (Hello Piel Frama), cheap plastic grips to hold in the iPad (Like the Yoobau slim). Some of these may seem relatively minor but the point is that the Vaja's seem to be the only cases that I have seen where I can't see a bad thing about them.
Yes the waiting time for them to be made is an issue however even the Agenda 2's now have certain colours in stock.
I know this sounds like a Vaja love fest but seriously I have tried loads of cases and nothing tops Vaja.