Preliminary findings (after a few hours of cursory "toying around;" I had a whole rant, but I have condensed it):
Cons:
- Ribbons being hidden when resizing the window to less than the width of the ribbon or to a height that is less than the "arbitrary height." This offers no way to access any of the menus at all. This is a problem in server-based computing and low screen res situations as it leaves the user with no access to any menu items.
Very bad. Ribbons also take up too much screen real-estate, and are very stiff in terms of configurable options (much like IE7.)
- No way to "enable Classic menus." This is a staple feature of other Vista upgrades such as IE7 and WMP11. And Vista's Explorer has this as well.
- Items in the title bar. Apple, Netscape and Microsoft need to be put out to dry for this abomination. 'Tis worse than drawers in OS X.
- Consistency broken: Excel uses the traditional multiple doc windows inside the main app window, Word uses multiple windows, Access uses multiple windows and a new tabbed interface, PowerPoint just has the updated GUI and Outlook has a piecemeal update. I assume it will be updated in the final version.
- Memory usage -- inserting some text upped the WINWORD.EXE process to a nice, healthy memory chunk of 50 megabytes. Worse than O
2.0, problematic in server-based computing ala Citrix, etc.
- Slow. Upon inserting a clip art image and applying one of those "oh-so-cool" effects, text insertion slowed to a crawl on a P4 2.4 GHz, 512 DDR RAM machine. Ridiculous.
Pros:
- The ribbon interface, for all its terrible implementations, is actually a much cleaner and intuitive UI than previous versions. They needed to do something about the menu options and now they have, and it works well.
- Add-in management seems to be cleaner, and exporting to PDF is nice. I want to see ODF support, though.
- Consistency of logos; though broken in XP (due to XP's old start menu look). The orb in the upper right hand corner mirrors vista's start menu icon. The reason this is nice is that it offers a consistent look and the file menu look similar to the start menu. Nice, though the menu is far too large.
- Contextual descriptions. Many items have a nice little description of what they do when you look at them. This is very nice.
- Word's side-by-side simultaneous scrolling is a great new feature that makes comparing documents VERY easy. Love it.
Yes, that
is the condensed version.
EDIT: Whoops, a bit of a typo there. Menu bar should have been title bar.