Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

sw1tcher

macrumors 603
Jan 6, 2004
5,483
19,235
It doesn't take much clicking to see that many, many other podcasts have had more listeners, were shared more frequently, and have made more of a buzz in the world.
So awards should be a popularity contest?

I haven't listened to the podcast either and have no intentions to, but an award should be given to something because of its quality, not it's quantity (i.e. having more listeners, having been shared more frequently, having more buzz, etc.)
 

ProfessionalFan

macrumors 603
Sep 29, 2016
5,829
14,788
I wonder if next year's award will go to the podcast highlighting human rights violations in China.
Silence there.

 

neuropsychguy

macrumors 68020
Sep 29, 2008
2,435
5,842
So awards should be a popularity contest?

I haven't listened to the podcast either and have no intentions to, but an award should be given to something because of its quality, not it's quantity (i.e. having more listeners, having been shared more frequently, having more buzz, etc.)
This is true. Let me add though that there is little chance this podcast would have won had it been the highest quality podcast and widely listened to but was 'anti-abortion'. This won in part because of the topic and message (as is the case with many other awards -- Academy, Grammy, etc.). That can be a problem because there could be objectively better podcasts (ones that are even much better and much more popular) that cover more benign topics but that will not win because their message isn't of a particular 'political' or moral slant.
 

TheDailyApple

macrumors 6502a
May 30, 2019
660
2,898
"Right side of history" has to be one of the dumbest and most meaningless sayings these days. It just means "the side I agree with" but they say it with such confidence like it is a true and meaningful statement.
Right side of history means the side that wins. After all, history is written by the victors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yaxomoxay

jonblatho

macrumors 68030
Jan 20, 2014
2,510
6,206
Oklahoma
Odd to never hear of the "podcast of the year" isn't it. Kinda says everything about this award.
I hadn’t listened to this season of Slow Burn yet (recently changed podcast apps and still working on bringing my old subscriptions over) but I’ve listened to and greatly enjoyed the earlier seasons; it’s a fair, interesting, and informative series. I’m not a big podcast listener either, so it has to be far from obscure if I know about it.
 

yaxomoxay

macrumors 604
Mar 3, 2010
7,411
34,214
Texas
“I’m glad I didn’t end up as an abortion.”
Steve Jobs, in Walter Isaacson's biography Steve Jobs

~~~

I’ll never forget sitting at the Mexican restaurant on Highway 24 in May 2020, reading this section of the book while eating lunch. It’s one of those life moments etched into my mind.

At birth, my name was Marquez Antonio Bowen. My father was listed as ‘unknown.’ I don’t know all that was going on in my mother’s life at the time (it seems nobody does), but it was decided that her mother would raise me—my grandmother—without me knowing the story. So, Marquez Antonio Bowen became Marcus Anthony Nixon. All through childhood, I had no clue that my older ‘sister’ was the one that actually gave birth to me, and I was too young and ignorant to ask why ‘mama’ was 40 years older than I was. No wonder that day as a child riding in the car, when I asked, “Do you remember the exact time I was born?” she responded, “I can’t remember. Ask your sister; she might remember.” The emotions that must have been in her mind at such a child-like question…

She eventually divorced her husband and remarried, so Marquez Antonio Bowen, that became Marcus Anthony Nixon, was now Robert Anthony Walker. That lasted a few years, and then ‘mama’ was murdered when I was 10. I still can visualize my older ‘sister’ arriving in the driveway and collapsing and crying like a baby while someone held her. It was in my mother’s will that if anything ever happened to her, my babysitters would become my parents, and they willingly did that Tuesday night in 1994.

The funeral came and went, and six days after the murder, we had a family meeting… I sat in my new ‘mama’s’ lap, and I found out that my ‘mama’ was not actually my mother. “Who is my mama?” At that point, my ‘sister’ started sobbing and repeating, “Please don’t hate me, please don’t hate me.” I hugged her and told her I didn’t hate her. I asked some questions that had no answers, and I grew up never bringing it up to her again. She loved me, made a hard choice, and I didn’t want to bring up any bad memories. She came to the hospital when my first daughter was born and was so excited. Sadly, she died of a seizure in 2010.

So, when I had a seizure in 2018, I naturally started wondering about my biological history and took a DNA test.You know that disclaimer on Ancestry’s website? “When using our Services, you may discover unexpected facts about yourself, or your family (e.g. you may discover an unknown genetic sibling or parent, surprising facts about your ethnicity, unanticipated genetic test results, or unexpected information in public records). Once discoveries are made, we can’t undo them.” LOL, Yeah, that disclaimer... you might uncover a script that would make a good Hallmark movie, an HLN docudrama, or something in between... oh me, oh my—maybe one day I can say more.

I have had three mothers who love me. My birth mother stayed in my life as an ‘older sister.’ My ‘mama’ raised me like her son though she was 40 years older than me and endured years of domestic abuse while doing the best she could for me. And the day she was murdered, my babysitter lost one of her best friends while getting a new son to raise. I’ve been loved by three women who consider me their son. I have no bitterness but am only filled with thankfulness. If I had any regrets, it would be personal and my personality—I know I am not the best sibling or son nor one to stay in touch as I should. Perhaps I won’t be an extreme introvert in heaven.

Having been that loved, I have no clue what is in a woman’s mind when making a choice such as the one that’s the topic of debate this week. My birth mother gave me to her mother, so clearly, she did not go down the path that is so much in this week’s news.

Whether Joanne Schieble and Abdulfattah Jandali have a child in Wisconsin that gets adopted, becomes Steven Paul Jobs, and changes the technological realm forever, or a young mother in Anderson gives birth to Marquez Antonio that becomes now middle-aged Tony in a little office at a country church south of Anderson, the famousness (or lack thereof) and the worldwide impact (or lack thereof) should make no difference in one’s ethic of life. We’ve all heard, “Don’t get an abortion! Your child might cure cancer!” Well, what if we say, “Don’t get an abortion! Your child might be a blue-collar worker that quietly loves his family, goes to church, loves Jesus, and dies of cancer with only a few people around him.” Whether someone cures cancer and lives long or dies early having accomplished little, does that make their life of any less worth?

You can search my FB history and find zero about politics, Obama, Trump, Biden, COVID, etc. There’s only so much in life you can care about and get outraged at. The older I get, the more I want to get outraged at my own sin and care about Jesus and my wife and kids. I’ll be dead in a few years, and I’m learning to focus on the stuff I can actually impact: my wife, my kids, about a dozen adults in SS, and a few dozen kids in the church youth department.

So, I purposefully stay ignorant of a lot of life’s controversies; there’s a lot in life I don’t know and stay out of. But I do know this: no matter how complicated the situation is, there is grace—common grace and saving grace—for the messiest of situations. Whether someone definitely impacts the world for many people or hopefully makes a small difference in the lives of a few people, one thing is certain…

They’ll never have the possibility if they never had the chance.
Thank you for this post.
 

zubikov

macrumors 6502
Sep 3, 2014
348
1,201
PA
So awards should be a popularity contest?

I haven't listened to the podcast either and have no intentions to, but an award should be given to something because of its quality, not it's quantity (i.e. having more listeners, having been shared more frequently, having more buzz, etc.)
You just made my point. Apple has an extremely large set of qualified potential award recipients to choose from. Instead of using more objective measures to signify impact, influence and reach, Apple has chosen to go the route of hand-picking an awardee based on highly subjective measures.
 

sw1tcher

macrumors 603
Jan 6, 2004
5,483
19,235
You just made my point. Apple has an extremely large set of qualified potential award recipients to choose from. Instead of using more objective measures to signify impact, influence and reach, Apple has chosen to go the route of hand-picking an awardee based on highly subjective measures.
Didn't know you had the 411 on how and what metrics Apple used to determine the winner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chocolaterabbit

IllinoisCorn

Suspended
Jan 15, 2021
1,217
1,652
Being on the right side of history helps me with their decision, but I imagine the podcasters are also good at what they do. Even is a podcast is the greatest quality, it might be tough for many people to support one that is pro White supremacy. That would be ridiculous.
"Pro white supremacy." Lol. It's amazing how many people think those they disagree with are just pure evil. Wow.
 

steevn

macrumors 6502
Jul 25, 2016
274
714
Well when people point out that slavery was ended by republicans, we're told the parties switched. So the "right side of history" changes based on who is saying it.
Because that statement is 100% true lol, their platforms did switch over time there is zero doubt about that.

37 republicans just voted against interracial marriage a few weeks ago, where does that fall in the line of “republicans can’t be racist they ended slavery”?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.