I don’t engage in #cancelculture. Criticism and ridicule through free speech are much more effective.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Pulls Hong Kong Protest App From App Store Following Chinese Criticism [Updated]
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I don’t engage in #cancelculture. Criticism and ridicule through free speech are much more effective.
Yup.. Exactly. Apple made a mistake by allowing it in the first place. Making the correction wasn't easy.
But of course... the keyboard warriors here will disagree. Problem is, they are just all talk. If they truly despised Apple for this, they would stop supporting Apple and leave the eco system immediately
Problem is criticism and ridicule has been cancelled in favour of pandering to the easily offended.
Tracking? You mean like a human voluntarily sharing information about a PUBLIC servant to another human? Seriously? You find that dangerous?
How would you feel if you and your workmates were the ones being tracked?
And this is acceptable?
"The app displays police locations and we have verified with the Hong Kong Cybersecurity and Technology Crime Bureau that the app has been used to target and ambush police"
Dude, please. Samsung's decision to move manufacturing out of China had absolutely ZERO to do with human rights. It had everything to do with the rising costs of manufacturing there and being able to build their phones cheaper elsewhere, like in Vietnam and India. When Samsung stops selling phones in China out of protest for human rights please get back to me.
"Pecunia non olet" guys. NBA, Blizzard, Apple, they're all the same, hypocrites full of ****
"endanger law enforcement and residents in Hong Kong" - actually it is the authoritarian socialists/communists in China that are "endangering the residents of Hong Kong.
Remember when the Macintosh was introduced Apple said 1984 wouldn’t be like “1984”? Wow was that wrong.
You mean like EVERYONE in China is being tracked and the people of Hong Kong want to try to avoid? Or is it only the socialists/communists that are allowed to do the tracking?
How everyone in China has a social score on how well they toe the line everywhere which then stops them from being allowed to buy a plane ticket etc?
Last edited:
No, this isn't right either.
So you agree the app should be removed as it's clear you disagree with the implications?
I am tracked... by the government. Wake up.
During WWII, in Nazi Germany, lots of companies turned against the regime, while other companies (like Siemens) served it. It was probably a similar situation at some point, tied to financial interests. But at some point you have to make a decision: to be entirely on the government's side, or to be entirely against them. Dictatorships use a "with us or against us" mentality to make as many people join them out of fear as possible. It starts with small things like this, then one day you are directly helping them design gas chambers.
As someone who has lived in an ex-communist country all my life, I have learned that you have to be 100% against the government the moment you start noticing hints of a totalitarian regime. If everyone decides what side they're on right in the beginning then the government never get the power to sway more and more people. It always starts with "Yeah I'll just do this one insignificant thing they want me to do, it's no big deal. At least they'll leave me alone." but soon they are driving tanks over people in the name of peace.
As someone who has lived in an ex-communist country all my life, I have learned that you have to be 100% against the government the moment you start noticing hints of a totalitarian regime. If everyone decides what side they're on right in the beginning then the government never get the power to sway more and more people. It always starts with "Yeah I'll just do this one insignificant thing they want me to do, it's no big deal. At least they'll leave me alone." but soon they are driving tanks over people in the name of peace.
Can you prove that? That’s so convenient of an accusation to make when the videos of police actually abusing the protesters are uh, everywhere...
I already have. Haven’t bought an iPhone in years.
Hey, as long as you keep making false gestures of acceptance toward the alphabet soup people, they’ll keep buying your products.
Selling is the goal. Everything else is a means to that end.
Absolutely pathetic from Apple. It confirms every negative stereotype people have suggested about Tim Cook.
He is happy to grandstand and virtue signal on twitter about whether illegal immigrants should be deported from America or about bathroom laws for transgender people. But an actual tyranny, one currently engaged in ethnic cleansing and crushing peaceful political dissent? Ah, Cook pauses, they build our stuff cheap and it's a big market... best not rock the boat.
There is an argument to be said for businesses to just concentrate on making money and have the government regulate them. Fine. But Cook must now forever be howled down with laughter and contempt every time he virtue signals on twitter. He has a choice and he is letting Apple side with tyrants trying to crush democracy and protest.
China is a brutal, blood soaked dictatorship. Read up about the Uighurs if you want to see their latest crimes. People like Cook often like to ask things along the lines of "what would you have done at a moment of great moral importance in the past?" Well, under Cook the answer is obvious. Money would come first. If he is happy to bow down to the Chinese government today then why would anyone believe he would have done anything else during, for example, the 1930s with the fascist governments? Think of all the noise made in the 1980s by people boycotting South Africa... yet what were they even buying from there in the first place? Easy to boycott things you don't need. Last year Cook was paid $136 million. Much of Apple's profits come from them keeping manufacturing costs down by building in China. In fairness to him how many of us would uphold principles about freedom if our mouths were being stuffed with that much gold? But he should never virtue signal on twitter again.
He is happy to grandstand and virtue signal on twitter about whether illegal immigrants should be deported from America or about bathroom laws for transgender people. But an actual tyranny, one currently engaged in ethnic cleansing and crushing peaceful political dissent? Ah, Cook pauses, they build our stuff cheap and it's a big market... best not rock the boat.
There is an argument to be said for businesses to just concentrate on making money and have the government regulate them. Fine. But Cook must now forever be howled down with laughter and contempt every time he virtue signals on twitter. He has a choice and he is letting Apple side with tyrants trying to crush democracy and protest.
China is a brutal, blood soaked dictatorship. Read up about the Uighurs if you want to see their latest crimes. People like Cook often like to ask things along the lines of "what would you have done at a moment of great moral importance in the past?" Well, under Cook the answer is obvious. Money would come first. If he is happy to bow down to the Chinese government today then why would anyone believe he would have done anything else during, for example, the 1930s with the fascist governments? Think of all the noise made in the 1980s by people boycotting South Africa... yet what were they even buying from there in the first place? Easy to boycott things you don't need. Last year Cook was paid $136 million. Much of Apple's profits come from them keeping manufacturing costs down by building in China. In fairness to him how many of us would uphold principles about freedom if our mouths were being stuffed with that much gold? But he should never virtue signal on twitter again.
Last edited:
It's funny everyone here pretending they support human rights whilst using devices and wearing clothes assembled in chinese sweatshops.
And they have the audacity to call Apple a hypocrite for simply removing an app.
And they have the audacity to call Apple a hypocrite for simply removing an app.
Think Waze. It’s a police tracking app.
Well put. As Chomsky said: "If you’re really in favor of free speech, then you’re in favor of freedom of speech for precisely the views you despise. Otherwise, you’re not in favor of free speech." It should have been blindingly obvious that when big tech decided to start silencing people - yes some of whom really were nutty, others were simply very conservative - that they would sooner or later abuse that power.