Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
63,768
31,226


The European Union is pressing ahead with legislation to heavily regulate companies like Apple, setting plans to force "gatekeepers" to open up access to hardware and software, and even set up an internal department to meet new rules, according to an endorsed agreement from the European Parliament's Internal Market Committee.

European-Commisssion.jpg

The provisional agreement on the Digital Markets Act (DMA) was reached earlier this week by EU governments, with 43 votes in favor, one against, and one abstention, showing a broad consensus from European lawmakers to aggressively regulate big tech companies. Apple is almost certain to be classified as a "gatekeeper" and be affected by the regulation due to the size of its annual turnover in the EU, its ownership and operation of platforms with a large number of active users, and its "entrenched and durable position" due to how long it has met these criteria, and will therefore be subject to the rules set out in the DMA.

The DMA could force Apple to make major changes to the App Store, Messages, FaceTime, third-party browsers, and Siri in Europe. For example, it could be forced to allow users to install third-party app stores and sideload apps, give developers the ability to closely interoperate with Apple's own services and promote their offers outside the App Store and use third-party payment systems, and access data gathered by Apple.

One of the more recent additions to the DMA is the requirement to make messaging, voice-calling, and video-calling services interoperable. The interoperability rules theoretically mean that Meta apps like WhatsApp or Messenger could request to interoperate with Apple's iMessage framework, and Apple would be forced to comply.

The latest provisional agreement sets out plans to establish a "High-Level Group" of central European digital regulators to coordinate national regulators across EU member states and requires "gatekeepers" to create an independent "compliance function." The new group must include compliance officers to monitor their company's compliance with EU legislation using sufficient authority, resources, and access to management, and be headed by an "independent senior manager with distinct responsibility for the compliance function." The rule would effectively require companies like Apple to set up an internal department dedicated to meeting pro-competition regulations.

In addition, new rules specifically targeted to address companies like Apple that have "a dual role" with control over both hardware and software look to allow any developer to gain access to any existing hardware feature, such as "near-field communication technology, secure elements and processors, authentication mechanisms, and the software used to control those technologies." This could have major implications for the level of integration that developers can achieve on Apple platforms, such as allowing contactless payment services to operate on the iPhone and Apple Watch just like Apple Pay.

EU lawmakers provisionally approved the DMA in March. Next, the proposals will be put to a final vote in the European Parliament in July before being formally adopted by the European Council and published in the EU Official Journal. 20 days after publication, the DMA will come into force and affected companies will have six months to comply.

Beyond the European Union, Apple's ecosystem is increasingly coming under intense scrutiny by governments around the world, including in the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, Japan, South Korea, and more, with a clear appetite from global regulators to explore requirements around app sideloading and interoperability.

Article Link: EU Planning to Force Apple to Give Developers Access to All Hardware and Software Features
 
Last edited:

xpxp2002

macrumors 65816
May 3, 2016
1,154
2,727
Yep, I’m sure that pulling out of a relatively affluent market of almost half a billion potential customers is right at the top of Tim Cook’s to-do list. Just right after he closes down the much smaller US market. ?
If this passes, Apple should just send an email and notification to every customer in the EU saying something to the effect of, “due to your government’s heavy-handed overreach, they will be blocking Apple from providing safe and secure services, like our App Store. As a result, we can no longer legally offer these services in the EU and will cease operations within 30 days.”

Just the threat of millions of devices losing iMessage, FaceTime, and the App Store framed properly will get the public on their side. I guarantee it’d turn this whole thing around within 48 hours.
 

Onelifenofear

macrumors 6502a
Feb 20, 2019
704
1,332
London
They have no idea what Security even mean - how can you make messaging systems interoperable.

Also are they PAYING for the huge amount of changes they are demanding for such a thing to happen which it can't ( see above ) - Also hilarious "they would have six months to comply."

Whats the point of making anything if the EU are effectively coming along and saying OPEN SOURCE all that. 40 Years of development, who cares, Redesigning communications ( along with Google ), 16 years of iOS upgrades and work - that's all ours now.

It's our consumer choice to have a closed system - I feel it's much safer and WAY more stable. Everything works as it should do for the most part.

Personally if I was in the EU, I'd get a class action suit ready to the EU for infringing my rights of security and substantially changing how our devices work behind our back.

There is of course one way around this. Create a 2nd OS iOS-EU that does all they want but can't access any Apple related features.
 

urnotl33t

macrumors 6502a
Jan 26, 2017
515
648
Cary, NC, USA
Sure, let's do this. Ransomware on iPhones, peoples most intimate secrets will be auctioned or posted openly, financial fraud on a whole new level, massive spy networks with secretly always-on cameras and microphones, ... yep, good times ahead. No more secrets, indeed.

I know I won't be installing certain apps ever again. Core apps from specific sources only, never any sort of "game" or "utility" app. I'd keep my device nearly pristine default-only.
 

urnotl33t

macrumors 6502a
Jan 26, 2017
515
648
Cary, NC, USA
The people against this forget it is optional... simply a win-win for the consumer and especially tech nerds who can do with their device what they like!

Check the definition of "fraud".

Tech Nerds also have an option with Android (in a past life, I was said gadget Tech Nerd; I "retired" from that post for myself). iOS was never targeted at the Tech Nerds.
 

steve62388

macrumors 68040
Apr 23, 2013
3,090
1,944
Yep, I’m sure that pulling out of a relatively affluent market of almost half a billion potential customers is right at the top of Tim Cook’s to-do list. Just right after he closes down the much smaller US market. ?
I don't think Apple will pull out of the EU. But consider this...

A tech company enters a territory with a huge population. The government creates laws hostile to that company. Said company pulls out despite the massive amount of money at stake. Local companies then go on to flourish and fill the gap left behind.

That company was Google and the territory was China. And as they have stated many times before, the EU is very eager to sponsor the growth of European tech companies.

There is precedence.
 
Last edited:

RadioHedgeFund

Cancelled
Sep 11, 2018
422
869
Sideloading and 3rd party app stores is a misnomer. Only 5% of Android users bother with anything outside the Google Play Store; this figure will be even less on iOS. Its nothing to worry about.

The messaging scenario will never work because everyone wants to maintain control. The EU would be better mandating that RCS become a continent-wide standard to officially replace SMS. If anything they should force the issue by forcing mobile networks to 'switch off' SMS from their networks by 2025. The UK would follow suit as most of the populace holiday on the continent. This would be similar to the analog switch off from a few years back.

The hardware issue is long overdue. Devs only have, for example access to a limited amount of RAM on iPad OS which severely limits the porting of Professional-level apps (AutoCAD etc) over to the platform. Given the M1 rollout across the iPad line we might have Mac apps running on it if we had more open architecture (you know, just like the Mac and PC)
 

RadioHedgeFund

Cancelled
Sep 11, 2018
422
869
I don't think Apple will pull out of the EU. But consider this...

A tech company enters a territory with a huge population. The government creates laws hostile to that company. Said company pulls out despite the massive amount of money at stake. Local companies then go on to flourish and fill the gap left behind.

That company was Google and that territory was China. And as they have stated many times, the EU is very eager to sponsor growth of European companies.
Ironically it wouldn't be so bad if there were more european phone manufacturers. Phone designs have become rather staid since american companies took over. Before that we had all sorts of ingenius designs from Nokia. Might be nice to get some european creativity back in phone designs vs american conservatism.
 

RadioHedgeFund

Cancelled
Sep 11, 2018
422
869
Sure, let's do this. Ransomware on iPhones, peoples most intimate secrets will be auctioned or posted openly, financial fraud on a whole new level, massive spy networks with secretly always-on cameras and microphones, ... yep, good times ahead. No more secrets, indeed.

I know I won't be installing certain apps ever again. Core apps from specific sources only, never any sort of "game" or "utility" app. I'd keep my device nearly pristine default-only.
I assume you also don’t install anything on your laptop either?
 

Beautyspin

macrumors 65816
Dec 14, 2012
1,009
1,174
If this passes, Apple should just send an email and notification to every customer in the EU saying something to the effect of, “due to your government’s heavy-handed overreach, they will be blocking Apple from providing safe and secure services, like our App Store. As a result, we can no longer legally offer these services in the EU and will cease operations within 30 days.”

Just the threat of millions of devices losing iMessage, FaceTime, and the App Store framed properly will get the public on their side. I guarantee it’d turn this whole thing around within 48 hours.
Just the kind of reaction that could net Apple a fine of its 10% of global revenue. Pull out and lose billions from this affluent market or follow the regulations and become complaint asap; those are the only two options. We all know which way Apple will go.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.