Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS I like the XS - am I the only one?
- Thread starter danneman
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Recently saw the iPhone XS Max. After a minute of using it I am so glad that the SX model exists that I got XS. The XS Max is gigantic. Good for teenagers who play games and watch movies or people with vision problems. For people who care about portability and productivity, XS size is perfect.
I love it. Works very well, and in a neat trick is actually smaller than I expected it to be - and feels smaller than I expected it to be yet looks HUGE to the eyes when looking at the screen. It's the first time I ever bought a smartphone on release, but given that this phone idea (all screen) has been a "thing" for me for some time now, I was eager to get this from the start.
I really expected more problems with mine, given the comments and the nature of cell difficulty that I've had with my situation. But this phone has performed at least as well as my more problematic earlier phones have, albeit I've only been able to do so much with it in a week. But I've sure tried to poke holes in it - and haven't been very successful on any level that justifies returning it.
I can't help but feel that it will get even better with updating, so given that it's "first day issue" with known bugs it's been a good experience so far - that I expect to get even better.
So yeah - I'm very pleased with the Max.
I really expected more problems with mine, given the comments and the nature of cell difficulty that I've had with my situation. But this phone has performed at least as well as my more problematic earlier phones have, albeit I've only been able to do so much with it in a week. But I've sure tried to poke holes in it - and haven't been very successful on any level that justifies returning it.
I can't help but feel that it will get even better with updating, so given that it's "first day issue" with known bugs it's been a good experience so far - that I expect to get even better.
So yeah - I'm very pleased with the Max.
I got the XS a couple days ago; traded in my X.
I love it. I went with the gold color - it's beautiful.
I love it. I went with the gold color - it's beautiful.
Yes, you're the only one out of millions who wanted and purchased the XS. Only you.
Went from a 6S to the XS and I'm 100% happy with it. No charging issues for me, LTE is fast (236 down) Wifi is fast (176 down (limited by my connection). A friend purchased the XS Max and it is HUGE... for me the biggest I'd want is the XS. the XR is probably even too big for my liking.
I upgraded from iPhone 6 to 7 Plus because I craved the extra vertical screen space and telephoto camera. I switched to XS because wider screen on 7 Plus made it harder to hold the phone comfortably. Now I have the best of the both world. I guess that makes me a mommy bear.
Went from a iPhone 7 to the XS. Fantastic upgrade regarding screen, speed, camera RAM, etc.
I have not noticed any of the issues reported other than a tendency to hang on to 2.4GHz longer than the 7, but even that might be just a perception rathe than reality. I hope to stick with it for three years.
I have not noticed any of the issues reported other than a tendency to hang on to 2.4GHz longer than the 7, but even that might be just a perception rathe than reality. I hope to stick with it for three years.
Honestly - I was a FaceID skeptic. Never looked back for a moment. It’s utterly seamless and makes touchID feel antiquated.
I had the X and it never was very responsive for both touch screen input, or Face ID unlock time. I thought something was wrong with my X screen & ended up trading it in for an 8plus. The new XS has solved both of these issues & I get MUCH better speakers and low light camera shots!
Apple is offering more choice that any other phone maker.
With the XR coming soon, you can even get multiple colors.
Having more choices is always good!
Pick your device color and size and enjoy!
With the XR coming soon, you can even get multiple colors.
Having more choices is always good!
Pick your device color and size and enjoy!
I can't speak for the XS because I decided to keep my X, but I think the size of the device is absolutely perfect. I went to an Apple store to check out the Max, and was happy I was able to leave without feeling tempted to purchase it. I like being able to sit comfortably with the X in my pocket, something I was not ever able to do with a plus size phone.
Absolutely no way Apple goes backwards and waists precious space inside the iPhone on a finger print scanner, when they solved and improved the problem with FaceID.
Not a chance in the world. 0% chance. None.
Sounds cool though!
I opted for the XS, given the only differences being the screen size and battery (both of which are somewhat trivial for my use case) and have no regrets. The Note 9 will satisfy my big canvas cravings
The XS is also a lot more convenient with my work dress code.
I am delighted with my XS. I can replicate the charging glitch and I do see the screen flutter on occasion but I have confidence that this will be rectified in software updates and so I'm unphased.
I think the camera 'beautification' conspiracy theories are laughable and have been used as PR exercises by overexcitable Youtube bloggers to nail Apple to a cross, even though they are probably sponsored by the competition. Do we really think Apple won't provide an option to neautralise the smoothing effect of the camera in future updates? I think not.
Between the XS and XS Max it's horses for courses and there is no clear winner.
I think the camera 'beautification' conspiracy theories are laughable and have been used as PR exercises by overexcitable Youtube bloggers to nail Apple to a cross, even though they are probably sponsored by the competition. Do we really think Apple won't provide an option to neautralise the smoothing effect of the camera in future updates? I think not.
Between the XS and XS Max it's horses for courses and there is no clear winner.
Last edited:
You need to start listening to yourself instead of comparing to what the “average” do.
I’ve been using a plus phone since it became a thing and after the 7+, I’ll be going to the XS as I’m tired of such a large phone. I can’t use this phone one handed without using reach ability like every 5 seconds.
I’ve been using a plus phone since it became a thing and after the 7+, I’ll be going to the XS as I’m tired of such a large phone. I can’t use this phone one handed without using reach ability like every 5 seconds.
They're both great phones. I could be happy with either.
I've gone from Plus -> X -> Max and would drop back down to something X-sized again if a year with the Max proves to be not worth the hassle.
I've gone from Plus -> X -> Max and would drop back down to something X-sized again if a year with the Max proves to be not worth the hassle.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t the XS’ screen around the same height as a plus model’s? It’s not as wide though, so that should help with reaching the top.
I bought a "non-max" XS last weekend, gold with 256 GB of storage. I was originally going to buy an iPhone 8 with the same amount of storage, but I spent too much time in the store comparing the displays between the two, so I opted for the XS. So I held my nose and paid the higher price. Although I still consider it somewhat overpriced (but I bought it in the end, so was it really overpriced?), and I absolutely love it. The calls sound better, I have quickly adjusted to the lack of a home button, the camera is better, and the display is better. It is beautiful with a forest green leather case with the gold stainless steel still visible. And my old 64 GB 6s was still running well and with a new battery (but I had used up all of the storage, which is why I upgraded). I kept the 6s as an iPod Touch/spare phone, since all I could get for it was a lousy $100 in a trade. The trade-in deals were much better 3 years ago. But the XS is a really nice device. I am very happy with it so far.
Two more things. I can already tell that the XS battery life is significantly better than the 6s. Finally, using a wireless has made me not miss the headphone jack, since I can charge and listen at the same time.
Two more things. I can already tell that the XS battery life is significantly better than the 6s. Finally, using a wireless has made me not miss the headphone jack, since I can charge and listen at the same time.
Last edited:
That's my dilemma right now. I'm returning my Max for the XS and so is my coworker. My hands are too small for the Max although the screen is beautiful.
Moved from an SE to an XS. It really only took a few days to get used to the size difference. Great screen and very responsive. Face ID works better everyday. And 12 seems very stable. Good move for me.