Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Newjackboy

macrumors 6502a
Aug 6, 2012
683
325
These guys are absolute geniuses

And u can be sure this system is already in constant use... at least initially for high profile security matters
 
  • Like
Reactions: rp2011

69Mustang

macrumors 604
Jan 7, 2014
7,895
15,044
In between a rock and a hard place
So explain to me how this gets installed on an iOS device. You can’t sideload anything without jailbreaking first, right? Apple’s App Store would have to miss the malware in its review process before it could made available to users, right? Sounds like the perpetrator would need physical access to the iOS device, right? Again, how does this make its way onto my iPhone 8?
Every year at DEF CON, iOS and other OSes are cracked by hackers via multiple vulnerabilities. Those vulnerabilities are disclosed and hopefully patched by the vendor. All vulnerabilities aren't disclosed. I seriously doubt any government agency is at DEF CON disclosing their tools for a $50K bounty. It's software sold to governments for targeted attacks. Customs and Border Patrol would be an easy vector for a government to physically access a target's devices. You're trying to frame this in the context of us, consumers. This issue really isn't about us... yet.
 

justperry

macrumors G5
Aug 10, 2007
12,558
9,750
I'm a rolling stone.
There is no such thing.

What a bold statement, do you have knowledge of each and every country in the world, did you live in other countries for an extended period of time, if so you must be the almighty allknowing god.
Please enlighten us...



Guess what, not all governments suck.

As for the article, I have my doubts, serious doubts.
 

centauratlas

macrumors 68000
Jan 29, 2003
1,824
3,771
Florida
What a bold statement, do you have knowledge of each and every country in the world, did you live in other countries for an extended period of time, if so you must be the almighty allknowing god.
Please enlighten us...

Guess what, not all governments suck.

As for the article, I have my doubts, serious doubts.


They may not all suck today, but as time progresses the chances that will continue fall dramatically. In short, they all will eventually suck at some point.

Today you may have person X, but tomorrow you may have Bernie/Trump/Hillary/Warren/Merkel/May/Macron/Chavez etc, pick whichever ones you despise and think about them having access to all your data.
 

laz232

macrumors 6502a
Feb 4, 2016
733
1,384
At a café near you
The news raises concerns that such spyware could be used by repressive regimes and other shady attackers to monitor members of the public.

Or, how about use by Western Democracies to track and place whistleblowers in jail? Whatever you may think of the specifics in, for example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russ_Tice, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Binney_(intelligence_official), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chelsea_Manning
One has to be completely blind and naive to believe that governments always act in the best interests of it's citizens - even in the USA / Europe.
 

CarlJ

macrumors 604
Feb 23, 2004
6,971
12,135
San Diego, CA, USA
In my experience, the average user doesn't understand the importance of backing up until their first hard drive failure.
Agreed, though the genius of iCloud backups for iOS is that there's almost zero friction to backing up this way (selecting "yes" at some point during the setup process, and plugging the device in overnight at least occasionally).

Backing up Macs, though, would be a very different animal - most of the space on iOS devices is taken up by things that can be reloaded from other sources: Apple doesn't need to keep unique copies of all your apps - they can just pull fresh copies from their App Store - they only need to back up the data you've created with those apps, similarly, if you download movies or music from iTunes, or photos that are already stored in iCloud, they don't need to keep unique copies of those in your backup data either. For many iOS devices, the backups are going to be a few gigabytes. On the other hand, Macs can get apps and data from all over the place, and the backups for a given Mac could easily run to hundreds of gigabytes. And there's more potential for large changes to that content, leading to much more daily traffic. I'm not sure Apple wants to take on that load.
 

laz232

macrumors 6502a
Feb 4, 2016
733
1,384
At a café near you
Boring news. Just assume every single communication and piece of data has or can be seen by anyone who wants it - because it can be. Snowden told us this years ago.

The problem is that being part of modern civilisation means that one is compelled to use these communications forms. It is not an option for me to be part of society and not be connected. Even if I avoid Facebook and Whatsapp as much as possible - forgoing email, forums etc would lead to extreme social isolation
 

nt5672

macrumors 68040
Jun 30, 2007
3,361
7,139
Midwest USA
Not surprised, encryption of iCloud communication and storage has been a frequently mentioned topic. If Apple gets on full encryption, we would all be better off.

Also, can we talk about how Apple isn’t offering iCloud Mac backups yet? Think of how much $ they are leaving on the table. Actually, I’m shocked they aren’t ready for this yet, they would be raking in the cash from people upgrading their storage to do backups.

I would not be surprised if they have been served with National Security Orders or political threats to prevent future development of security features like these.

After all, today Apple is basically a marketing company that produces so-so technology, so why should they get their underwear in a wad if their users can be monitored. They only thing that will get them going is bad press like this because they are certainly not going to spend major bucks protecting their users unless not protecting them is seen as damaging their brand.
 

Mousse

macrumors 68040
Apr 7, 2008
3,500
6,727
Flea Bottom, King's Landing
In my experience, the average user doesn't understand the importance of backing up until their first hard drive failure.
My experience, even professional tech people fail to back up their stuff more often than they care to admit.:oops: Y'all have heard the stories about some CGI movies were almost lost because someone wiped the network drives, only to be salvaged because an animator had a copy they were working on at home.

Is it just me, or does anyone find in annoying a hacker group calls itself a security company? Call a spade a spade. None of that, your terrorist is my freedom fighter rubbish.
 

Mr_Brightside_@

macrumors 68040
Sep 23, 2005
3,748
2,037
Toronto
Agreed, though the genius of iCloud backups for iOS is that there's almost zero friction to backing up this way (selecting "yes" at some point during the setup process, and plugging the device in overnight at least occasionally).

Backing up Macs, though, would be a very different animal - most of the space on iOS devices is taken up by things that can be reloaded from other sources: Apple doesn't need to keep unique copies of all your apps - they can just pull fresh copies from their App Store - they only need to back up the data you've created with those apps, similarly, if you download movies or music from iTunes, or photos that are already stored in iCloud, they don't need to keep unique copies of those in your backup data either. For many iOS devices, the backups are going to be a few gigabytes. On the other hand, Macs can get apps and data from all over the place, and the backups for a given Mac could easily run to hundreds of gigabytes. And there's more potential for large changes to that content, leading to much more daily traffic. I'm not sure Apple wants to take on that load.
iCloud Backup for iOS works beautifully, but the friction comes into play when people use up their free 5 GB. I've witnessed so many people dismiss the popup to add more storage space - who become the same people who complain when their phone takes a swim and their last backup was six months ago.
 

nt5672

macrumors 68040
Jun 30, 2007
3,361
7,139
Midwest USA
Lol. You think the USA and Uk equivalents just sit and twiddle thumbs all day?

they’re also doing it

Thanks to a few patriots and freedom fighters like Snowden and Assange we now know that the USA is one of the biggest threats to mankind. The USA can justify just about any action without any reason whatsoever internally or in any other country.

Our current government (including both republican and democrat political sides) makes me sick and does not represent what America's people should stand for. It also is the reason why we must de-power the US government at every level through peaceful protests and voting. At this point in time there is no reason important enough to give the US government more power. Period.
 

PygmySurfer

macrumors 6502
Aug 7, 2006
330
63
Wellesley, ON
Is it just me, or does anyone find in annoying a hacker group calls itself a security company? Call a spade a spade. None of that, your terrorist is my freedom fighter rubbish.

This. Can we stop calling these companies "Security Firms" and call them what they actually are, Black Hat Hackers. A Security Firm would provide Apple with details on the exploits, so they could be corrected. These guys are instead leaving users vulnerable, and selling them out to governments (and who knows who else).
 

now i see it

macrumors G4
Jan 2, 2002
10,671
22,342
so everything on your phone stays on the hackers phone too

Probably the most harmful narrative  has barfed out these last few years is that their stuff is secure. Wake up world, It's not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mactendo

Glockworkorange

Suspended
Feb 10, 2015
2,511
4,184
Chicago, Illinois
If encrypted iCloud Mac Backups were available, I would instantly upgrade my iCloud Plan to 1TB. This would be awesome
I think I give BackBlaze $10.00 a month for this service. They back up my Mac plus any drives attached and I don't think there is a storage limit. I can't see Apple offering anything close to that. Can you imagine a 2 TB hard drive and then like 4 TB's of external discs?
 

DoctorTech

macrumors 6502a
Jan 6, 2014
736
1,962
Indianapolis, IN
I wonder how this can be detected by a user? I’m thinking of various countries now, and more likely in the future, that want to confiscate your phone at a border crossing/airport international arrival. Would they all install this as a matter of course? It makes me think one might consider setting up a fake iCloud account and tie your phone into that while traveling and wipe/restore your phone to the original iCloud account after passing through the borders.
I have seriously considered purchasing a burner phone that isn't tied to anything for international travel then turning on call forwarding and leaving my iPhone at home. It may sound extreme but I really don't like the idea of having some nimrod demand I unlock my phone or having them take my phone / tablet out of my line of sight for a few minutes.
 

08380728

Cancelled
Aug 20, 2007
422
165
their claims about selling it to only legitimate authorities are as filmsy as it gets.
i wonder who audits their claims

Did you stop reading at that point?

Nevermind everyone else seemed to have read up to

“ is only sold to responsible governments to help prevent terrorist attacks and criminal investigations.”

No one pay any attention the the following:

“However, the WhatsApp flaw was used to target a London lawyer who has been involved in lawsuits against the NSO Group, and security researchers believe others could have been targeted as well.”


Yanks go blue in the face about a Russians, not a peep out of them about Israelis who are the most malicious group with a long history of these type of exploits...remember them infecting and hostile taking over Iranian nuclear power station control systems?

Bah freak show planet....
 

Crowbot

macrumors 68000
May 29, 2018
1,706
3,920
NYC
Did you stop reading at that point?

Nevermind everyone else seemed to have read up to

“ is only sold to responsible governments to help prevent terrorist attacks and criminal investigations.”

No one pay any attention the the following:

“However, the WhatsApp flaw was used to target a London lawyer who has been involved in lawsuits against the NSO Group, and security researchers believe others could have been targeted as well.”


Yanks go blue in the face about a Russians, not a peep out of them about Israelis who are the most malicious group with a long history of these type of exploits...remember them infecting and hostile taking over Iranian nuclear power station control systems?

Bah freak show planet....


Just to keep it straight, they disabled a centrifuge network that was refining uranium. Not a power station.
 

lederermc

macrumors 6502a
Sep 30, 2014
897
756
Seattle
As they are a company in a fairly western democracy, that will be regularly audited by both government and private regulators and accounting firms, the liklihood of what you're claiming is probably low.

however. One of their customers "leaking" or being hacked ad having it stolen? Probably high.

Like almost all security exploits, once it's discovered by one team, the cat is out of the bag and others will likely follow and repeat the exploit.
And the vendors will close the exploit.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.