Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Carrier List of eSim providers (Prepaid vs Postpaid)

Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
ImAnAgent

ImAnAgent

Suspended
Oct 11, 2018
273
213
My mind
pika2000 said:
Wow, such convoluted mess. Why do we want this instead of simply putting a physical SIM inside a phone?

I fail to see the logic of eSIM. Unless Apple becomes the provider hosting all the carrier options so user can directly choose carriers via Apple, I don’t see the point of eSIM.
Click to expand...
I've had a lot of bad luck getting prepaid eSims to work on T-Mobile. Last week, I lost a prepaid account when I restored my XS Max. Upon restoring my backup, the prepaid account was nowhere to be found. T-Mobile prepaid support could not get the account added back onto my iPhone so I gave up on that account. I was never given the option to keep the eSim account before I restored.

Today, I signed up for another account to replace the one above and the XS Max never got provisioned for the account and I could never setup the account online either since the eSim was not activated. T-Mobile support over the phone was worthless and T-Force on Twitter could not get the system to accept the EID. Gave up on that account and they credited the funds I was charged to my postpaid account immediately.

The prepaid phone support lady kept asking me to open the phone and remove the eSim so I could give her the number on it. I just hung up on her.

Setup a third account shortly after and this one was successful.
 
ImAnAgent

ImAnAgent

Suspended
Oct 11, 2018
273
213
My mind
mreg376 said:
Hahaha! You must not get out much...
Click to expand...
I've pretty much done the same thing as the person you quoted. T-Mobile has gotten so congested here in Denver that I barely get 1.5Mbps at my job now. I've gotten an AT&T account to use while I am at my job as well as an Xfinity Mobile account.

Xfinity Mobile (Verizon) has much better coverage and speeds then T-Mobile and AT&T in my area. I don't seem to have any congestion on AT&T and Xfinity Mobile and my speeds have topped out at 211Mbps on XfInity Mobile.

Once I pay off my iPhones on AT&T, I may very well just switch to Xfinity, it's that good.
 
George Knighton

George Knighton

macrumors 65816
Oct 13, 2010
1,391
346
mreg376 said:
Hahaha! You must not get out much...
Click to expand...
LOL.... Are you talking about coverage or data speed, or both?

For practical purposes, for me, where I normally live, travel and work, there's little difference between T-Mobile and Verizon coverage, although in many parts of this same area Verizon's data speeds can be much faster no matter the time of day.

ImAnAgent said:
I've pretty much done the same thing as the person you quoted.
Click to expand...
I think he was making fun of me for not believing that there was a huge difference between T-Mobile and Verizon.

:)
 
D

DeanL

macrumors 65816
May 29, 2014
1,297
1,237
London
ImAnAgent said:
I've had a lot of bad luck getting prepaid eSims to work on T-Mobile. Last week, I lost a prepaid account when I restored my XS Max. Upon restoring my backup, the prepaid account was nowhere to be found. T-Mobile prepaid support could not get the account added back onto my iPhone so I gave up on that account. I was never given the option to keep the eSim account before I restored.

Today, I signed up for another account to replace the one above and the XS Max never got provisioned for the account and I could never setup the account online either since the eSim was not activated. T-Mobile support over the phone was worthless and T-Force on Twitter could not get the system to accept the EID. Gave up on that account and they credited the funds I was charged to my postpaid account immediately.

The prepaid phone support lady kept asking me to open the phone and remove the eSim so I could give her the number on it. I just hung up on her.

Setup a third account shortly after and this one was successful.
Click to expand...

That is extremely weird.
Restores with iTunes never erase eSIMs, and via the iPhone settings it explicitly asks whether or not you want to keep the eSIM...
[doublepost=1552109840][/doublepost]
OBirder said:
USA:

AT&T Postpaid

- Keep blue eSIM card - can be reinstalled after phone wipe or phone swap
Click to expand...

That’s incorrect. After 1-2 days, the QR code can’t be used to reprovision the phone. It will give an error message.
Also it can’t be used for phone swap. Once you activate it on a phone, it can only be reinstalled on that same phone for 1-2 days after which it expires but once never on another phone.
Source: I tested it multiple times .
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: George Knighton
catean

catean

Suspended
Jun 16, 2013
531
555
London, UK
Orange has launched eSIM in Romania, this Wednesday, 27 March 2019. At the moment only for iPhones, we are still waiting for Apple Watch cellular support.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RvXtm
C

coldwaves

macrumors 6502
May 30, 2011
414
203
When I was looking for a data plan for international travel, I came across a data service provider called RedteaGO. Its website is esim.plus. For most destinations it offers 1GB data for 30 days in eSim. The price is slightly cheaper than GigSky and Truephone. Has anyone had any experience with them?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheMadBrewer and catean
catean

catean

Suspended
Jun 16, 2013
531
555
London, UK
Guys, do you have any idea why apple does not allow us to have 2 eSIM profile active? This seems like a software limitation not a hardware one.
 
RvXtm

RvXtm

macrumors regular
Jul 11, 2011
137
81
Timisoara, Romania
catean said:
Orange has launched eSIM in Romania, this Wednesday, 27 March 2019. At the moment only for iPhones, we are still waiting for Apple Watch cellular support.
Click to expand...

We also need the cellular apple watch models. The ones sold in Romania are all non-cellular. Unless you get it from the black market.
 
catean

catean

Suspended
Jun 16, 2013
531
555
London, UK
RvXtm said:
We also need the cellular apple watch models. The ones sold in Romania are all non-cellular. Unless you get it from the black market.
Click to expand...
Orange are bringing the cellular AW from 12th of April in Poland, so probably we are next. Summer time, at the same time as Apple Pay would be great.
 
TheMadBrewer

TheMadBrewer

macrumors regular
Feb 11, 2008
206
44
Marina del Rey, CA
catean said:
Yes

Yea, it works as advertised. I tested Truphone, Gigsky and Ubigi, and they all connected to 4G network and delivered reasonable download/upload speeds.
Click to expand...

Thanks. I'm going to give one a try on next month's trip to Berlin and Prague. Gigsky is probably out as their plans are shorter than my trip, down to Truphone or Ubigi.
 
T

tabilo

macrumors member
Mar 15, 2012
37
80
TheMadBrewer said:
Thanks. I'm going to give one a try on next month's trip to Berlin and Prague. Gigsky is probably out as their plans are shorter than my trip, down to Truphone or Ubigi.
Click to expand...

If you are not bound to an eSIM, get yourself a local physical SIM card (e.g. AldiTalk) or if you really need an eSIM Deutsche Telekom (be aware, as of writing this, you won't get 3G/4G in the Berlin subway with this card)
Ubigi is only supporting 3G in Germany, which both supported providers are actively replacing with 4G (especially in Berlin, you will not be happy with a 3G only SIM). All local SIM cards are without roaming charges in the EU.

More infos:
https://prepaid-data-sim-card.fandom.com/wiki/Germany
 
  • Like
Reactions: catean
TheMadBrewer

TheMadBrewer

macrumors regular
Feb 11, 2008
206
44
Marina del Rey, CA
tabilo said:
If you are not bound to an eSIM, get yourself a local physical SIM card (e.g. AldiTalk) or if you really need an eSIM Deutsche Telekom (be aware, as of writing this, you won't get 3G/4G in the Berlin subway with this card)
Ubigi is only supporting 3G in Germany, which both supported providers are actively replacing with 4G (especially in Berlin, you will not be happy with a 3G only SIM). All local SIM cards are without roaming charges in the EU.

More infos:
https://prepaid-data-sim-card.fandom.com/wiki/Germany
Click to expand...

I actually have a couple of prepaid EU SIM cards (Vodafone NL, Fonic DE) but I need to also have my US number. Originally I hoped to move my T-Mobile postpaid to the eSIM and a put local SIM in the physical slot but it looks like T-Mobile has bailed on postpaid eSIM (yes, I know you can call and sometimes they will do it but "unsupported.") So rather than carry an extra phone I will try one of these data only eSIM plans. Since there is no commitment I can drop them if TMO ever comes around.
 
C

cere

macrumors 6502
Jun 3, 2008
465
52
TheMadBrewer said:
Looks like they are back (at least for a while) -- I was able to sign up with Ubigi...
Click to expand...
Did you notice if they let you pick the start date for the service? Ubigi has a 30% off data plans for the next couple days and they are much cheaper than GigSky or Truphone. But I’m not travelling to Europe for another month so I’m wondering if I can signup for a plan now but have it start mid June.
 
TheMadBrewer

TheMadBrewer

macrumors regular
Feb 11, 2008
206
44
Marina del Rey, CA
cere said:
Did you notice if they let you pick the start date for the service? Ubigi has a 30% off data plans for the next couple days and they are much cheaper than GigSky or Truphone. But I’m not travelling to Europe for another month so I’m wondering if I can signup for a plan now but have it start mid June.
Click to expand...

I don't think they let you pick a start date. I bought a 30 day plan a week before my trip starts but I'm only over there for 16 days so it will work for me. But I have to admit I wasn't looking for that so I may have missed a link -- don't think I did but I could have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cere
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom