I see your point but I would prefer it to be stated as things “I don’t like” about it, and even “don’t want” it. The part about whether they return or not doesn’t help me at all personally.
But I get that it is probably semantics and not really that different. Also people will share anyway, so it’s kind of irrelevant. I still manage to filter everything out but the important information.
I see your point and sorta feel the same.... returning often is a financial decision and hence highly subjective. Tells me nothing about whether I should buy, return, or keep. I too prefer to hear about people's experiences and then let me decide how I feel about it and how it fits into my world (or not).