Glad too see I'm not the only one who loved that game so much!Until Dawn
Well I would say Uncharted 2.
But then along came The Last Of Us, and I have never had a game take me in such an engrossing story as that! The most perfect game for me bar none!
For current gen, so far I’d say DOOM cause it’s mad fun and Forza horizon 3, oh and Halo Wars 2. Oh and Gears Of War, any of them, they kinda redefined the shooter for me.
Valkyria Chronicles
Fallout 4 (especially Far Harbor, haven't played Nuka World yet)
GTA V
Yakuza 4
Sleeping Dogs
Yakuza 4 is the game that got me into the Yakuza series. And for me, it's easily one of the best games I played on PS3.
I enjoyed Nier and its a nice game, but I don't think I'd call it a favorite game, especially given the negatives you wrote. I don't think it matters that its a sequal to a masterpiece. The game on its own is ok, but no where near the depth of other games. Just my $.02Well I think it would have to be NieR Automata for me. As an open world game, it's not so great... It also lacks the amount and variety of content I would expect for an RPG, and it's not terribly challenging (at least not in a rewarding way), but it's a sequel to a masterpiece, and a masterpiece in its own right in terms of storytelling, music, character development, and philosophical exploration---and those things matter more to me than gameplay.
As a big fan of Metroid who had never heard of Axiom Verge, thanks! This game looks awesome and I'll definitely buy it.Not my #1, but I just wanted to mention Axiom Verge. If you like Metroidvania, this is the game for you. I got every secret.
A wonderful INDIE title that was another sleeper for me was FEZ. Give it a shot if you have yet to play it.