The “put anywhere” should never the the default. An option? Maybe. Default? No. the doc mode layout is something that helps the user. If they want to make “put anywhere” an option, maybe. But i think, they could innovate by offering updates or options on the doc mode layout itself. Its good that icons flow to a certain location. That makes organization *more easy*. If they want to add an option to change *where the icons flow to* or “icon flow” ‘’’
Icon flow or doc mode layout
Left to right, top to bottom
Right to left, top to bottom (they already have this for locations in the world where languages flow this way)
They could also add
“Right to left, *bottom to top*” to appease users who want better reachability. It could also be called “reverse doc mode” or something like that
In addition to the “no doc mode” where users could put the icons anywhere. But just make it an *option only*, and not “the new way”
Xpost: the doc mode layout (auto-aligned left to right top to bottom) of app icons is a good thing though. without it, you have icons floating around randomly all over the place. the doc mode layout adds a good amount of organization, a "center of gravity", if you will, that allows users to place "new or important" icons in a certain place (the top left). if they want to make this new thing (freely floating icons) an *option*, that could be ok, but I think it should be just that - an option. to *remove* the existing "doc mode layout" that's there, that actually takes away functionality, because, as it stands, the existing setup creates a nice simple organized look, where, if you want to call attention to something, you know where to put it: the top left. what they could do, is, ..it seems like people maybe want a "reverse doc mode", so that, in addition to the existing doc mode (left to right, top to bottom), they could add the ability to choose a "reverse doc mode layout" where apps would auto-align right to left, bottom to top. but to just have the sort of stock android layout, where it's just like, throwing icons all over the place kind of randomly, i don't see how that really helps. if people want it, make it an option, but don't change the existing default. if anything, add an *option* to change the size of the grid so that users can add more icons, and more widgets in the same amount of space.