Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
63,616
30,987


Smartphone manufacturers supplying the EU will be required to provide spare parts for at least five years from the date of a device's introduction and ensure longer battery life, according to new draft proposals published by the European Commission.

European-Commisssion.jpg

The Financial Times reports that the proposals would require at least 15 different component parts to be made available and that batteries should survive at least 500 full charges without deteriorating to below 83 percent of their capacity.

Phones sold in the EU would also have to display an energy efficiency label, similar to those used for washing machines and dishwashers, showing expected battery life and other characteristics such as the device's drop resistance.

The draft regulations cover tablets and mobile phones, and are based on the claim that by making hardware more repairable and recyclable, the energy consumption involved in a device's production and use would be cut by a third.

Currently, owners of iPhone, iPad, iPod, Mac or Apple TV products can obtain a service and parts from Apple service providers, including Apple Retail Stores and Independent Repair Providers, for a minimum of five years from when Apple last distributed the product for sale.

After five years, iPhones are typically classified by Apple as "vintage" and Apple can still service these devices if it has the parts. After seven years, devices are classed as "obsolete" and hardware servicing is no longer available.

Apple in April launched its own Self Service Repair program, which allows users to complete their own repairs via a new online store dedicated to parts and tools, but the service is currently only available in the United States, although it will be expanding to additional countries, including Europe, later in 2022.

The new proposals also cover software, and require manufacturers to provide security updates for five years after devices leave the market and functionality updates for three years. Apple has typically offered software support to iPhones for almost a decade after they are released, but owners of Android phones typically receive only a few years of software updates, so the regulations are likely to greatly impact Google.

Smartphone makers critical of the draft proposals have argued that making more parts available actually increases the consumption of plastic, resulting in wasted resources, but the EU has warned that products which do not meet its sustainability requirements "will go off the market."

The latest draft EU proposals follow a requirement introduced in June for smartphones to use a standardized charger by 2024, despite years of opposition from Apple.

Article Link: EU Draft Proposals Require Phone Makers to Provide Spare Parts for 5 Years and Ensure Longer Battery Life
 

contacos

macrumors 601
Nov 11, 2020
4,732
18,386
Mexico City living in Berlin
“Ensuring longer battery life”

Ok, good luck enforcing that lol.

Not really that hard. You can check how many charging cycles your phone went through and if it’s below 83%, well then they would have to service the battery for free. Presumably for 5 years?

Or if the device fails their battery test overall, they can slap a C or D eco friendly label on it
 

kiranmk2

macrumors 68000
Oct 4, 2008
1,538
1,998
Hopefully this will make Apple implement a way to allow you to stop charging the phone before 100% (or keep a bit of battery reserved to 100% doesn't actually mean the battery is completely full).

Fast and wireless charging are also not helping battery health - iPhones since the 8/X definitely seem to have lower battery health after 1-2 years than phones such as the 6s/7....
 

laptech

macrumors 68040
Apr 26, 2013
3,582
3,986
Earth
Am not sure what the EU is doing here because back in the 90's the EU brought in a directive that required manufacturers of electronic consumer goods to provide spare parts for upto 5 years because of the use of Extended warranties which was purchased as an optional extra. The reason I know this because I was working for a mobile phone manufacturer that was based in the EU and the company issued a memo to the warehouse manager that due to new EU legislation the company had to keep spare parts for upto 5 years and that he needed to reorganise the warehouse to cater for this new legislation. The warehouse got so full of spare parts that the company bought 3 shipping containers that they filled with spare parts of old mobile phones of which they had to keep.

I can therefore only think that what the EU is doing is updating existing legislation.
 

xxray

macrumors 68040
Jul 27, 2013
3,041
9,161
Not really that hard. You can check how many charging cycles your phone went through and if it’s below 83%, well then they would have to service the battery for free. Presumably for 5 years?

Or if the device fails their battery test overall, they can slap a C or D eco friendly label on it

I wasn’t interpreting it that way. From the quote below, I assumed they meant how long the daily battery life on the phone is and how efficient the phone is:

Phones sold in the EU would also have to display an energy efficiency label, similar to those used for washing machines and dishwashers, showing expected battery life and other characteristics such as the device's drop resistance.

You’re correct that measuring physical/chemical battery longevity would be easier.
 

contacos

macrumors 601
Nov 11, 2020
4,732
18,386
Mexico City living in Berlin
Hopefully this will make Apple implement a way to allow you to stop charging the phone before 100% (or keep a bit of battery reserved to 100% doesn't actually mean the battery is completely full).

Fast and wireless charging are also not helping battery health - iPhones since the 8/X definitely seem to have lower battery health after 1-2 years than phones such as the 6s/7....

You can already do that with a shortcut. E. g. Stop charging when battery level reaches 80%

Edit: nvm read it wrong
 

lilkwarrior

macrumors regular
Jul 9, 2017
151
92
San Francsico, CA
“Ensuring longer battery life”

Ok, good luck enforcing that lol.
Exactly; what exactly does that mean? Similarly, what are "functionality updates' to enforce for three years? Do they seriously think they can tell engineers what to backport to older models as far as features?

Who would audit features that arguably can be in older models; what technical expertise would they have to judge that?

Five-year spare parts seem arbitrary and not very green at all. That's ancient in the world of tech. EU registration team just seems to be full of tech-illiterates with good-sounding intentions.
 

gigapocket1

macrumors 68020
Mar 15, 2009
2,246
1,733
it'll probably be cheaper for most companies to not keep spare parts and after a while.. Just give customers a newer model....
 
  • Like
Reactions: CriticalVoice

FreakinEurekan

macrumors 603
Sep 8, 2011
5,597
2,668
Assuming one charge daily, 500 is less than one a half years... pretty sure most decent manufacturers will meet or exceed this already.
500 “Full” charges, or what Apple calls a “Charge Cycle.” So five charges from 80% to 100% = 1 “Full” charge. Apple does currently warrant batteries to last for “80% of its original capacity at 500 complete charge cycles” - within the first year. It’s unclear if this will extend battery warranty past the first year, without additional coverage (e.g. AppleCare+). Likely, it would be like existing Consumer Law where the warranty itself isn’t affected, but consumers in affected areas can claim CL coverage.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DownUnderDan

rorschach

macrumors 68020
Jul 27, 2003
2,273
1,860
I understand security updates, as a security vulnerability could potentially affect a lot of people.

I don’t understand "functionality updates”. So manufacturers will be required to add features? Why? If you buy a product that is advertised as doing a, b, and c, and three years later it still does a, b, and c, then what’s the problem?

Feels like a lot of people have developed a sense of entitlement with these free software updates. Look at all the complaining every time 4-5 year old devices that have gotten literally hundreds of new features since its original release — for free! — don't get a few of the new features with the latest update.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.