I just received my new 16" MacBook Pro (2.3 i9/32GB/1TB/5500M 4GB). I have an original UltraFine 5K purchased when I bought my 2016 MPB.
In clamshell mode (my normal setup), if I plug the UltraFine into the left side of my 16", everything works fine. However, if I plug it in on the right side, the display remains black.
If I run with the lid open and plug the UltraFine into the right side port, both screens continuously turn on and off. The actual display never appears on either, they just flash on and off.
I am using Apple's 0.8m Thunderbolt 3 cable.
Has anyone seen anything like this? Is it possible my MBP is defective?